Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best for Home Cooks: Instant Pot Lux 6-In-1 Programmable Pressure Cooker at Amazon
"Has steadily gained a cult following as an appliance that can make just about any foods."
Best Modern: Kalamera 24” Wine Cooler at Walmart
"Now that you’ve really honed in on your tastes as a couple, register for something you’ll really use and enjoy."
Best for Home: Brooklinen Luxe Hardcore Sheet Bundle at Brooklinen
"Splurge on an extra-luxurious set of sheets to update your bed."
Best for Her: Stone & Beam Black and White LOVE Word Art at Amazon
"Cool but sentimental art that can serve as a starting point for a lifetime of collecting art together."
Best for Foodies: Two Tumbleweeds Foodie Dice at Amazon
"Your challenge is to roll the dice, then try to concoct a dinner using the ingredients you rolled."
Best for Bohemians: Rumi Sumaq String Surf Bracelet at Amazon
"A unisex multi-strand bracelet for a casual take on anniversary jewelry."
Best for Him: Enkore Agate Coasters at Amazon
"Selected for their fine ocean shades and polished to a party-ready sheen."
Best for Jokesters: Big T Ranch Denture Soap Set at Amazon
"If humor is one of the things that keeps your relationship, er, fresh, this will certainly help."
Best for Home Cooks: Instant Pot Lux 6-In-1 Programmable Pressure Cooker
Another appliance that might not have been on your radar when you registered: the Instant Pot. This programmable pressure cooker debuted in 2010, but has steadily gained a cult following in just the last few years as an appliance that can make just about any foods, from slow cooker favorites like chili and stews to popcorn, desserts and more. Fans of the appliance have developed a whole suite of their own recipes and cookbooks, but for a newly married couple–especially one that might be adding to their family soon—it’s all about convenience and ease of preparation with this appliance that does everything a pressure cooker can do and more.
Best Modern: Kalamera 24” Wine Cooler
A more modern four-year-anniversary gift tradition is to choose an appliance, and that makes sense: Maybe when you registered for gifts, you were afraid of asking for too much, or didn’t know what you would use, or had a vision for what kind of married people you’d be that may not have actually panned out. That’s fine, not all of us are meant to live on homemade veggie juice!
Now that you’ve really honed in on your tastes as a couple, register for something you’ll really use and enjoy, like a wine fridge. This 46-bottle cooler can either be installed into a built-in space or work freestanding, so you can use it in the kitchen, basement or even a corner of the living room. It can be set to a range of temperatures to get the perfect chill for your favorite wine, and will automatically set to your last saved temperature should the power go out, and it’s virtually silent when it runs so it’s not adding noise pollution to your space.
Best for Home: Brooklinen Luxe Hardcore Sheet Bundle
If you registered for a set of sheets when you were first married, chances are the years of weekly laundering — plus that one time or the other when a ballpoint pen or red sock got into the wash — have made those once-crisp linens dull or worn. No wonder that linen and silk are another traditional four-year anniversary gift! So splurge on an extra-luxurious set of sheets to update your bed.
This bundle of bedding includes a sheet set, duvet cover and extra pillowcases to fulfill your full suite of bedding. It’s all made in extra-luxe 480 thread count cotton weave for a breathable, silky-soft feel. And the bedding is incredibly popular from buyers who love the silky, warm and comfortable feel.
Best for Her: Stone & Beam Black and White LOVE Word Art
As you’re building a home together, what usually happens is that you focus on the basics — sofas, shelves, beds and towels — then lose momentum when it comes to choosing the decorative accessories that really make your house a home. So start to nest a little with cool but still sentimental art that can serve as a starting point for a life of collecting art together. This small-ish print (it’s 14” square) can work in just about any room, as a standalone piece or as part of a gallery wall with an eclectic mix of artwork. It's the perfect gift for her, for a daily reminder of how much you love her.
Best for Foodies: Two Tumbleweeds Foodie Dice
One of the easiest ways to keep a relationship fresh is to explore new things together, and cooking is a fun one to play with since you can do it together in the comfort of your own home, and then enjoy the delicious results (or have a new story of a cooking disaster to share!). This kit is clever: Your challenge is to roll the dice, each of which has a different food group or kind of ingredient on it (like cooking methods, grains, veggies, herbs and proteins), then try to concoct a dinner using the ingredients you rolled. Being creative together and problem-solving to build a meal will surely bring you closer together, especially if you don’t take it to seriously — and solve the problem with a glass of wine in hand.
Best for Bohemians: Rumi Sumaq String Surf Bracelet
The traditional colors for the four-year anniversary are blue and green, colors of loyalty and vitality that your marriage is earning as you move from being newlyweds to just plain married people. But instead of investing in the traditional blue topaz or zircon, stones that can seem quite fancy on a still-shoestring lifestyle, consider a unisex multi-strand bracelet made from hand-knotted nylon for a casual take on anniversary jewelry. The bracelet works just as well for men as for women and stands up to water, sun, sports and more. In brilliant shades of aqua with metallic accents, it’s lighthearted but durable, much the way you want your relationship to be.
Best for Him: Enkore Agate Coasters
Another twist on the tried and true blue and green anniversary “stones” is a set of agate coasters in deep jewel tones of sapphire and emerald. Much like a marriage partnership, the true beauty of these stones is found inside and created only over the course of many years — an analogy you can use as a jumping-off point for a thoughtful card to accompany them. The set includes four coasters, each between 3.5” and 4.5”, and each totally unique as the variations are naturally grown in the stone. They are selected for their fine ocean shades and polished to a party-ready sheen. He can put them to use in his man cave or perhaps now he will actually use a coaster.
Best for Jokesters: Big T Ranch Denture Soap Set
Last but not least, a humorous twist on a promise to love your spouse forever: Denture-shaped soap that says you’re in it for the long haul. This handmade soap comes as a set of two (top and bottom, of course!) and is available is three luscious scents, including cake batter and black raspberry vanilla (yum!). Your spouse will enjoy placing them in the soap dish in the powder room to get a good reaction from houseguests, or using them every morning in the shower to start the day with a smile on their face. If humor is one of the things that keeps your relationship, er, fresh, this will certainly help!