Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Armor All 2-Piece Black All Season Truck/SUV Rubber Floor Mat
Our best overall pick, the Armor All 4-Piece All Season Rubber Floor Mats combine the best of everything and still ring in at an affordable price. The four-piece set can be customized to fit any vehicle after some trimming, and you’ll get two front and two rear mats in your choice of black, tan, or gray. These mats are designed to never curl, crack, or harden (even in sub-zero weather), so they're a good choice if you live in an area that experiences snow and ice. They also feature “Carpet Claw” anti-slip backing, so they’ll stay in place and won't slip under your feet. Many customers commented that the color matches the interior of their car well, providing a seamless look.
Best Set: FH Group All Weather Floor Mats, 4 Piece Set
When you need to balance your budget with keeping your car clean, go for these FH Group floor mats. You can’t beat a four piece set that comes in under $30 and can withstand all weather conditions. The front mat dimensions are 29 x 18 inches, while the rear is 17.1 x 14 inches. Don’t worry if these don’t fit perfectly in your vehicle, as they're easy to trim with some scissors. These mats are waterproof and stain resistant, but they're easy to clean if they do become soiled. They’re specifically designed with ridges to trap water, dirt, mud, and sand and prevent them from leaking onto your carpet. You’ll also get to choose between several different colors to suit your vehicle’s style.
Best for Winter: Motor Trend MT-923-BK Black FlexTough Contour Liners
Winter is probably the toughest time of year to keep your car clean, and that’s why you need a car floor mat that is durable enough to last through the season (and many more to come). These Motor Trend universal fit mats (two front mats and two rear liners) are durable can be trimmed to fit any vehicle—just cut away through the lines until you find the fit that works for you. They also have a no-slip grip, so once you find your fit, you can be assured the mats will stay in place.
Ergonomic grooves give your feet added traction if they’re wet, and the flex tough advanced performance rubber polymers are tested for the most extreme conditions (think rain and snow storms), so they’re guaranteed to be durable and hold up over time. You won’t have to swap your mats once winter ends, either—these are all weather, so they’re built to handle rain, snow, mud, and more. When it’s time to get rid of the mess, the mats are easy to remove and clean up.
Best Rubber: BDK Heavy Duty 4pc Front & Rear Rubber Floor Mats
If you want to stick with rubber mats, you can’t go wrong with these BDK heavy duty rubber floor mats. These have a universal fit, so whether you have a car, truck, or SUV, these can be trimmed to fit inside. These mats are heavy, so you can be assured you’ll have all season weather protection. Whether it’s raining, snowing, or your kids were out playing in the mud, these can handle it. They’ve got heavy duty waterproof capabilities to keep out literally all moisture, and they’re also stain resistant. And don’t worry about the cleanup—these mats are removable so you can shake them out or use soap for tougher messes. All you need is soap, water, and a soft brush to get the rubber back to new. Finally, rubberized nibs on the bottom ensures your mats will stay in place.
Best Odorless: Motor Trend DeepDish Car Floor Mats 4 Pcs with Cargo Trunk Mat
Arguably one of the worst parts of using a car floor mat is the strong smell, but these Motor Trend rubber mats eliminate any odor concerns. This set, which includes two front liners, two rear liners, and a cargo trunk mat, comes in your choice of beige, black, or gray, and the mats are semi-custom fit, so they’ll work in most cars. These mats are a little more costly at over $40, but there are some major reasons to spend a little extra. They’re built for durability, so not only are they thick and heavy duty, but they can also protect against all weather conditions, including rain, snow, and mud. The best part, though, is that the rubber is 100 percent odorless. According to online reviews, this is a definite perk. “No rubber smell. I am very happy with my purchase and would recommend them to anyone," said one customer.
Motor Trend Permium Carpet Car Floor Mats - 4 Pieces Thick Carpet Cushion Mat
If you’ve got carpet floors and want to match your mat to it, opt for a carpet floor mat, like these Motor Trend thick carpet cushion mats. Not only will they help keep your car interior feeling cohesive, but carpet mats also add a little bit of comfort, too. These mats are great because they’re affordable, and you’ve got your choice of colors to make sure you match your vehicle’s interior. You can choose between black, beige, charcoal, or gray, and thanks to the universal fit, you’ll be able to use these whether you drive a truck, car, or SUV. These mats are extra thick, so don’t worry about carpet not being as durable as rubber. These are strong and dense and can be used in all seasons. Once they get dirty, they’re easily washable. Thanks to a rubberized needle backing, they won’t slip or skid as you get in and out of the car.
Best for Trunks: BDK Heavy Duty Cargo Liner Floor Mat
If you’re transporting pets, sporting equipment, or frequently use your trunk for trips to your local garden center, you want to make sure your trunk is protected, and that’s why this BDK cargo floor mat is perfect. The heavy-duty rubber polymer mat comes in black, gray, and beige, and can be trimmed to fit most vehicles. Because your trunk sees plenty of wear and tear, this mat is extra thick, so it’s extremely durable. The material is guaranteed for all weather protection, so no matter if it’s raining, snowing, or dusty outside, this will keep your trunk protected. Non-slip backing ensures it’ll stay in place on any fabric or carpet surface.
Best Luxury: FH Group All-Season Diamond Heavy-Duty Anti-Skid Backing Faux Leather Floor Mats
Dressing up your car is super easy, thanks to these FH Group luxury diamond floor mats. You can ride in style with black, faux leather, lightweight mats featuring a sleek diamond design. They might not seem all that practical, but they actually are. The faux leather is waterproof, and these are made for all seasons, so they can effectively trap water, dirt, and spills from your car floor. Textured backing keeps them locked in place, and the material is not only luxurious, but it’s also sturdy, so it’s guaranteed to last a long time. These are light and easy to remove when it’s time to clean them, and don’t worry about any leather smells—these mats are completely odorless! No matter what kind of car your drive, these mats will work.