A cozy, not-too-heavy comforter is key to a good night’s rest. If it’s too hot or too lightweight for your tastes, for example, you’re not going to sleep well. We spend one-third of our lives in bed, so a pattern of poor sleep can start to affect your health. In the end, finding the perfect comforter—like many other kinds of bedding—comes down to personal preference, but there are still a few standout products that can kick off your search.
Luxe sleepers might enjoy a down comforter—a bit pricier... option than some other materials, but one that can definitely be worth the splurge. Allergy sufferers might need to look for a down alternative option. For those who get really cold at night? Wool just might be your best bet. And for anyone that runs hot when they sleep, a lighter comforter is definitely in order. Here are some of the most popular and well-reviewed comforters available to make your search for the perfect cover easier.
This tops the list of best comforters because it’s an affordable option that works well for most sleepers. It’s 100 percent hypoallergenic with siliconized fiberfill alternative fibers that help resist dust mites and mold spores, thus reducing allergy symptoms while you sleep. And the filling won’t shift around thanks to its quilted box stitch construction. Another benefit of this one is that you can machine wash it and tumble it dry.
Customers describe it as fluffy, soft, and luxurious feeling. One even said that it’s so comfortable she never wants to get out of bed. Another compared it to what you would find in a high-end hotel room, adding that the fabric stays cool on hot nights, but keeps you warm when it gets chilly. Some have warned of holes developing in the fabric while others have had some issues with the filling getting ruined during the machine wash. The company has a 30-day money back guarantee, if you’re not satisfied.
If you like the feel of being snuggled up in a luxurious down comforter, this is a great choice. For those who suffer from allergies but want a feather comforter, this one is backed by an allergy-free warranty and the Hyperclean stamp, meaning dust, dirt, and allergens have been removed. While it should be dry-cleaned, it only needs to be sent to the cleaners every three to five years.
In terms of how it feels, this comforter has great insulation but is also breathable enough that you won’t overheat. The cover is a soft, 500 thread count of Egyptian cotton, so even if you use it without a duvet cover you’ll be comfortable having it near your face. And you’ll sleep better knowing it comes with a 10-year limited warranty.
One customer said it’s a beautiful comforter, and another described it as warmth without the weight. Some have complained about the down not staying in place, saying it sometimes shifts to the end of the comforter. But the majority of consumers who have purchased it would recommend it.
Whether you have allergies or simply want animal-free bedding or an affordable alternative to down, the Superior Down Alternative Comforter would be a good choice for keeping cozy at night. Available in a medium weight that works for all seasons, it has 100 percent poly-fill and with a microfiber shell that is breathable. There is a baffle box construction that keeps the fill from moving around over time.
Reviewers note that is plush and keeps them nice and toasty at night but doesn't overheat. Many have chimed in years after the purchase that this comforter has held up over time.
Wake up in a sweat every night? A warm, heavy comforter is probably not going to give you a good night’s sleep. Instead, you should look for a lightweight cover that will keep you just warm enough without overheating. This down alternative comforter is a good option. It’s made with 100 percent new polyester filling and has a microfiber embossed cover with box-stitched construction so the filling stays firmly in its place. It’s also hypoallergenic and easy to clean in the washer and dryer.
More than a thousand customers have reviewed it online, and the majority of consumers agree that it’s a great comforter. One who said they get extremely hot at night praised its lightweight and breathable feeling. Others have said they love how soft it is and how it holds up in the washing machine. In terms of complaints, some have said it’s too thin to put in a duvet cover, but if you’re looking for a light, cool comforter or blanket, this will get the job done.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
Want the luxury feeling of a down comforter but without the feathers? Whether it’s because of allergy concerns or concerns about animal rights, a down alternative cover might be the right choice for you. This one is filled with 100 percent hypoallergenic allergy-free poly fiber and has box stitching to keep it all in place. You can also machine wash it.
To make sure this comforter stays in place inside your duvet cover, it has four corner tabs that can be tied into place inside the duvet. That means you won’t end up with all the warmth concentrated down by your feet when you’re sleeping.
Customers have described it as very fluffy, like you’re sleeping on a cloud. It’s also very soft and can be used year-round. Some have warned that while it does say you can machine wash it, you should use caution, and it can fall apart when washed too often. But many say for the price, it’s a quality purchase.
An Amazon best-seller, the LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter proves buyers don’t need to spend a fortune for a comforter that will work no matter what the thermostat reads. The shell is made of 100 percent polyester, while the filling is made of microfiber – both hypoallergenic materials that won’t cause irritation like down.
Reviewers say the LinenSpa comforter is soft and warm but not too warm, though there are a few dissenters who say it’s still a touch too cozy for the summertime. Most owners say the box stitching does a good job of keeping the fill in place to ward off hot or cold spots, though a few say they think the stitching could be higher quality. It’s safe to clean in the washer and dryer, and there are loops to keep duvet covers secure. But buyers may not even need a duvet cover – this comforter comes in reversible color combos including navy and graphite; sand and mocha; and stone and charcoal. White is still available for traditionalists.
If you’re picky about comforter size, you’re in luck: the LinenSpa comforter comes in twin, extra-long twin, full, queen, oversized queen, king, oversized king, and California king. It’s backed by a three-year warranty.
Like to sleep under the weight of several blankets? Then this comforter filled with 100 percent Australian wool might just be for you. It has a 300 thread count, cotton jacquard cover for added coziness. Wool can be another good option for those who are allergic to down. But keep in mind that just like your favorite wool or cashmere sweaters, this comforter will need to be dry cleaned when it’s time for it to be laundered.
One consumer describes it as light, yet extremely warm, a good alternative to a down comforter. Customers have also praised its durability and how well it’s made. A few have complained about the wool smell and warned if you have dust allergies, this might not be the best comforter for you. But if you’re looking for a quality wool cover, it’s a good choice.
At The Spruce, our Expert writers are committed to researching and writing thoughtful and editorially independent reviews of the best products for your life and your family. If you like what we do, you can support us through our chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn more about our review process.