Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet at Amazon
“It’s an affordable option that works for most sleepers.”
Best Lightweight: LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter at Amazon
“The reversible comforter is warm but not too warm.”
Best Down Alternative: Superior Alternative Comforter at Amazon
“The microfiber shell is breathable and works for all seasons.”
Best for Hot Sleepers: Buffy Comforter at Buffy
“The plant-based comforter shell is much lighter than cotton.”
Best Down: ROSECOSE Goose Down Comforter at Amazon
“Feels like sleeping on a cloud and will keep you warm.”
Best Budget: Chezmoi Alternative Comforter at Amazon
“For the price, it’s a quality purchase.”
“Customers praise the durability, weight, and warmth of this option.”
01 of 07
Best Overall: Utopia Bedding Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter Duvet
This tops the list of best comforters because it’s an affordable option that works well for most sleepers. It’s 100 percent hypoallergenic with siliconized fiberfill alternative fibers that help resist dust mites and mold spores, thus reducing allergy symptoms while you sleep. And the filling won’t shift around thanks to its quilted box stitch construction. Another benefit of this one is that you can machine wash it and tumble it dry.
Customers describe it as fluffy, soft, and luxurious feeling. One even said that it’s so comfortable she never wants to get out of bed. Another compared it to what you would find in a high-end hotel room, adding that the fabric stays cool on hot nights, but keeps you warm when it gets chilly. Some have warned of holes developing in the fabric while others have had some issues with the filling getting ruined during the machine wash. The company has a 30-day money back guarantee, if you’re not satisfied.
02 of 07
Best Lightweight: LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter
An Amazon best-seller, the LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter proves buyers don’t need to spend a fortune for a comforter that will work no matter what the thermostat reads. The shell is made of 100 percent polyester, while the filling is made of microfiber – both hypoallergenic materials that won’t cause irritation like down.
Reviewers say the LinenSpa comforter is soft and warm but not too warm, though there are a few dissenters who say it’s still a touch too cozy for the summertime. Most owners say the box stitching does a good job of keeping the fill in place to ward off hot or cold spots, though a few say they think the stitching could be higher quality. It’s safe to clean in the washer and dryer, and there are loops to keep duvet covers secure. But buyers may not even need a duvet cover – this comforter comes in reversible color combos including navy and graphite; sand and mocha; and stone and charcoal. White is still available for traditionalists.
If you’re picky about comforter size, you’re in luck: the LinenSpa comforter comes in twin, extra-long twin, full, queen, oversized queen, king, oversized king, and California king. It’s backed by a three-year warranty.
03 of 07
Best Down Alternative: Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter
Whether you have allergies or simply want animal-free bedding or an affordable alternative to down, the Superior Down Alternative Comforter would be a good choice for keeping cozy at night. Available in a medium weight that works for all seasons, it has 100 percent poly-fill and with a microfiber shell that is breathable. There is a baffle box construction that keeps the fill from moving around over time.
Reviewers note that is plush and keeps them nice and toasty at night but doesn't overheat. Many have chimed in years after the purchase that this comforter has held up over time.
04 of 07
Best for Hot Sleepers: Buffy Comforter
Wake up in a sweat every night? A warm, heavy comforter is probably not going to give you a good night’s sleep. Instead, look for a lightweight cover that will keep you just warm enough without overheating. This plant-based comforter shell (made with spa-grade eucalyptus fabric) is a great option for hot sleepers, as it's much lighter than cotton.
Users report that the Buffy is “basically a cloud” and “pure bliss”, and the Internet seems to agree. This ultra-fluffy, cozier-than-cozy comforter has been praised in pretty much every publication known to humankind in the last year, thanks to its uncanny ability to be both lightweight AND just the right amount of warm. Best of all, the Buffy is cruelty-free and made from recycled plastic bottles, so you can sleep easy at night knowing you’ve done your part to protect and preserve the environment.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Down: ROSECOSE Luxurious Goose Down Comforter
If you like the feel of being snuggled up in a luxurious down comforter, this is a great choice. For those who suffer from allergies but want a feather comforter, this one is Hypoallergenic and allergy free, meaning dust, dirt, and allergens have been removed. While it should be dry-cleaned, it only needs to be sent to the cleaners every three to five years.
In terms of how it feels, this comforter is very fluffy and feels like sleeping on a cloud. It's 100% cotton with 750+ fill, so even on cold winter nights it will keep you nice and warm. The 1200 thread count also adds to the soft, luxurious feel. It comes in three different sizes: twin, queen, and king.
This product has garnered rave reviewers from customers, who say that it "feels like a cloud" and the "quality of the comforter is well worth the price." Some have complained that it's very warm, so this may not be the best option for hot sleepers. But the majority of consumers who have purchased it would highly recommend.
06 of 07
Best Budget: Chezmoi Collection White Goose Down Alternative Comforter
Want the luxury feeling of a down comforter but without the feathers? Whether it’s because of allergy concerns or concerns about animal rights, a down alternative cover might be the right choice for you. This one is filled with 100 percent hypoallergenic allergy-free poly fiber and has box stitching to keep it all in place. You can also machine wash it.
To make sure this comforter stays in place inside your duvet cover, it has four corner tabs that can be tied into place inside the duvet. That means you won’t end up with all the warmth concentrated down by your feet when you’re sleeping.
Customers have described it as very fluffy, like you’re sleeping on a cloud. It’s also very soft and can be used year-round. Some have warned that while it does say you can machine wash it, you should use caution, and it can fall apart when washed too often. But many say for the price, it’s a quality purchase.
07 of 07
Best Wool: OrganicTextiles Australian Natural Wool Filled Comforter
Like to sleep under the weight of several blankets? Then this comforter filled with 100 percent Australian wool might just be for you. The wool filling and cotton shell are natural and organic, so you can rest assured that it's free from harsh chemicals and pesticides that are harmful to your body.
One customer said that if you're in the market for a wool comforter, it's a good balance between quality and cost. Customers have also praised its durability and weight. If you're looking for a hypoallergenic option (wool is naturally resistant to dust mites, mold, and mildew) that's warmer than down, this is a great choice. It's also machine washable for easy cleaning!
How We Tested
We bought three top-rated comforters and our reviewers tested them for more than 300 hours. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using these comforters, from their material to their durability. We've outlined the major takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What to Look for in a Comforter
Fill You’ll pay a premium for down (goose is usually more expensive than duck) and feather options, but they’re the softest and most breathable. Synthetic options feel similar and are hypoallergenic, but because they tend to retain heat, they aren’t ideal for people who sweat a lot.
Loft Also known as fill power, a comforter’s loft indicates the amount of space one ounce of filling takes up. Comforters with a higher loft are fluffier and have better insulation. If you like something lightweight, a fill power below 400 will suffice, while if you’re looking for a year-round option, choose a comforter in the 400-600 range. If you’re looking for something even warmer, opt for a loft higher than 600.
Box construction Box construction refers to the way a comforter is stitched to keep the filling evenly dispersed. There are two main types: sewn-through box and baffle box. In sewn-through box construction, the top and bottom layers of a comforter are sewn together in a box pattern. In a baffle box construction, strips of fabric are sewn between the top and bottom layers to create compartments. Baffle box construction is more expensive but more effective at keeping the fill in place.
Test Results: Utopia Bedding Hypoallergenic Down Alternative Comforter Duvet (Best Overall)
What We Like
What We Don't Like
Doesn’t hold up well after washing
Compared to similar comforters, this one was “softer and fluffier,” according to one of our testers. One reviewer also said that “it’s definitely worth it for the price point” because of its high-quality fabric, and that it was great at regulating body temperature: “The texture and weight of this comforter definitely made a difference in my sleeping comfort,” she reported. Our testers didn’t have anything critical to say about this comforter, but some online reviewers noted that it became flat after they washed it.
Test Results: LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter (Best Lightweight)
What We Like
Lightweight but warm
What We Don't Like
Texture feels unnatural
Fabric holds wrinkles
“Honestly, I was very pleasantly surprised by the quality of this comforter for the price,” declared one of our testers. “It's not high end, but it does the job and was much less sweat inducing than my regular comforter. It was lightweight but still warm.” On the other hand, our reviewers noted that the fabric wrinkled easily and one reviewer thought that its material “felt too silky for my taste and almost slippery.”
Test Results: Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter (Best Down Alternative)
What We Like
Lightweight but warm
Thick and fluffy
What We Don't Like
Not as breathable
One of our testers thought that this comforter was a “great hypoallergenic option” and was impressed with the “texture of the shell as well as the level of warmth delivered for the weight.” Our reviewers also loved its thickness and fluffiness. In terms of negatives, one tester thought its breathability was “a little lacking” and had concerns about the quality of the stitching: “The stitching on the shell seems looser than the double stitching around the edge,” she noted.