Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert at Amazon
"An ideal all-season blanket that's affordable and machine-washable."
Best for Hot Sleepers: Buffy Comforter at buffy.co
"This eco-friendly comforter is light to keep you from overheating."
"This high-end comforter is filled with ethically sourced European down."
Runner-Up, Best Down: Brooklinen Down Comforter at Brooklinen
"Filled with down clusters and boasts a baffle-box construction."
Best Down Alternative: Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter at Amazon
"Has the same feel as down but at a lower price."
Best Lightweight: All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter at Amazon
"Delivers on warmth but won’t weigh you down at night."
Best Splurge: Alberta Euro Down Comforter at Home Depot
"This hypoallergenic comforter provides unbeatable loft and warmth."
Best for Summer: Hydrocool™ Down-Alternative Duvet Insert at Pottery Barn
"Made with moisture-wicking fibers designed to keep you cool."
"Reviewers say this comforter is soft and well-made."
01 of 09
Best Overall: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert
Comforters are an essential part of any bedding set because they're what keep you warm at night. If you're looking for a warm, well-made comforter at a good price, you can't go wrong with the Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert. It's a soft, cozy duvet that has thousands of glowing reviews. And did we mention it’s under $50?
This comforter comes in twin, full, queen, king, and California king sizes, as well as four plain colors. However, it’s designed to be used with a duvet cover, as it includes loops where you can tie a cover on. The Utopia Comforter is filled with a siliconized fiberfill that makes for an ideal all-season blanket, and it has box-style stitching to keep the fill evenly distributed. Plus, it’s machine-washable, so you don’t have to take it to the dry cleaner!
Reviewers say the Utopia Bedding Comforter is cloud-like and incredibly warm during the winter, even though it feels light to the touch. Plus, many note you can’t beat the incredibly low price!
02 of 09
Best for Hot Sleepers: Buffy Comforter
Do you always end up getting hot during the night and tossing your blanket off? Then you need a product like the Buffy Comforter, which is lightweight and airy, keeping you from overheating. The fill in this unique comforter is made from 100 percent recycled polyester that’s spun from BPA-free, PET water bottles, so you can feel good about your purchase knowing it’s helping the environment, too!
Buffy comes in twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king sizes, and the soft exterior shell is made from eucalyptus fabric. The blanket is filled with a number of layers of fill to give it an extra-fluffy appearance and fill, yet it’s still incredibly breathable, making it perfect for hot sleepers. Reviewers say it’s something you would find in a luxury hotel, and the company even offers a free trial so you can see if you like it.
03 of 09
Best Down: Alberta Euro Down Comforter
If you’re partial to down comforters, you’ll love the Alberta Euro Down Comforter, which is plush, warm, and elegant. This high-end blanket comes in twin, full, queen, and king sizes, and it’s filled with ethically sourced European down that’s rated at 600-650 fill power.
The Alberta Euro Down Comforter has a 300-thread count cotton shell that’s combed for added softness. It comes in five different colors, each of which are neutral enough to fit in with your existing color scheme. You can choose from three different warmth levels—light, medium, and extra warmth. The baffled box construction keeps the down from shifting around, creating warm and cool spots. The down is hypoallergenic and silent as you shift around, and reviewers say its solidly constructed and durable.
04 of 09
Runner-Up, Best Down: Brooklinen Down Comforter
Another unbeatable choice is the Brooklinen Down Comforter, which comes from a highly regarded bedding brand. You can choose from either a lightweight option, which is 600 fill power, or an all-season comforter, which is 700 fill power, and there are twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king/California king sizes.
This comforter is filled with down clusters instead of feathers, and it boasts a baffle-box construction to keep the fill in place. There are duvet cover loops if you want to dress up your blanket, but you might not even want to given how soft the 400-thread count cotton sateen shell is! The Brooklinen Down Comforter has more than 1,000 positive reviews and a near-perfect average rating—reviewers say it’s “like sleeping wrapped up in a soft fluffy cloud” and extremely high quality.Continue to 5 of 9 below.
05 of 09
Best Down Alternative: Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter
Down is often viewed as the gold standard of bedding material, but many people are actually allergic to goose down and the material is also quite expensive. For these reasons, down alternatives have become popular—they give the same look and feel of down, but for a lower price. One of the best down alternative comforters available today is this option from Superior Solid, which is soft, fluffy, and completely hypoallergenic.
This versatile white comforter comes in twin/twin XL, full/queen, and king sizes, and it can be used on its own or with a duvet cover. The microfiber shell is filled with a lofty polyester fill, which makes it look and feel like down and will keep you warm on cold nights. Reviewers love how fluffy this comforter is and people say it holds up incredibly well, even after numerous washings.
06 of 09
Best Lightweight: LINENSPA All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter
Some people love the feeling of a heavy blanket—hence the popularity of weighted blankets lately—but others prefer a lighter comforter to sleep under. If you fall into the second camp, you’ll enjoy the Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Quilted Comforter, which delivers on warmth but won’t weigh you down at night.
This comforter comes in all the standard blanket sizes, as well as twin XL, California king, oversized king, and oversized queen. There are seven reversible colors and patterns to choose from, and the comforter is filled with a hypoallergenic down alternative. The exterior is a soft microfiber fabric with a boxed stitch finish, and there are eight loops where you can attach a duvet cover, if you choose. Reviewers say this blanket is incredibly lightweight and fluffy, making it the ideal comforter to use in the summer.
07 of 09
Best Splurge: Alberta Euro Down Comforter
If you have a little extra money to spend, you won’t regret investing in the Alberta Euro Down Comforter. This down-filled blanket is made with only the highest quality materials, so it’s hypoallergenic, durable, and incredibly warm and luxurious. It comes in five colors, as well as three warmth levels, depending on your preferred sleeping temperature!
This blanket is filled with 600-650 fill power hypoallergenic European down (fill power is a measure of fluffiness), so it won’t aggravate your allergies, yet you’ll still get unbeatable loft and warmth. The exterior is made of 300-thread count combed cotton sateen that’s lightweight, soft, and drapes beautifully, and it has 12-inch baffle box stitching to keep the down evenly spread throughout the blanket. There are corner loops if you want to attach a duvet cover, and as an added bonus, this comforter can be cleaned in your own washer and dryer—uncommon among down blankets.
08 of 09
Best for Summer: Hydrocool™ Down-Alternative Duvet Insert
Hot summer days often feel too warm for a comforter, but you’ll be able to sleep comfortably under the Hydrocool Down-Alternative Duvet Insert. This blanket has moisture-wicking fibers that are specially designed to keep you cool and dry throughout the night, making it the ideal comforter for summer.
This duvet insert comes in full/queen and king/California king sizes, and there’s only one color option as it’s designed to be used with a duvet cover. The exterior is 300-thread count cotton with a damask stripe pattern, and the interior is a polyester down alternative. You can machine wash the blanket, making for easy care, and it’s made in the USA, too.Continue to 9 of 9 below.
09 of 09
Best Budget: Ella Jayne All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
Comforters can get quite pricey, but you don’t have to drain your bank account to get a quality blanket, thanks to the Ella Jayne All-Season Comforter. This down alternative blanket comes in twin, full/queen, and king sizes, as well as seven colors, and all of the options are incredibly affordable, starting around just $25.
You can use this blanket on its own or secure it inside a duvet cover, and its down alternative polyester fiberfill will keep you warm in the winter or cool in the summer. The exterior is made from a triple-brushed microfiber, which is soft and cozy, and it has a baffle box construction to keep the fill from clumping or shifting. Reviewers say this comforter is incredibly soft and well-made, and many note it’s light enough to use in the summer.
Products Tested by The Spruce
How We Tested
We bought three top-rated comforters and our reviewers tested them for more than 300 hours. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using these comforters, from their material to their durability. We've outlined the major takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What to Look for in a Comforter
Fill You’ll pay a premium for down (goose is usually more expensive than duck) and feather options, but they’re the softest and most breathable. Synthetic options feel similar and are hypoallergenic, but because they tend to retain heat, they aren’t ideal for people who sweat a lot.
Loft Also known as fill power, a comforter’s loft indicates the amount of space one ounce of filling takes up. Comforters with a higher loft are fluffier and have better insulation. If you like something lightweight, a fill power below 400 will suffice, while if you’re looking for a year-round option, choose a comforter in the 400-600 range. If you’re looking for something even warmer, opt for a loft higher than 600.
Box construction Box construction refers to the way a comforter is stitched to keep the filling evenly dispersed. There are two main types: sewn-through box and baffle box. In sewn-through box construction, the top and bottom layers of a comforter are sewn together in a box pattern. In a baffle box construction, strips of fabric are sewn between the top and bottom layers to create compartments. Baffle box construction is more expensive but more effective at keeping the fill in place.
Test Results: Utopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert (Best Overall)
Doesn’t hold up well after washing
Compared to similar comforters, this one was “softer and fluffier,” according to one of our testers. One reviewer also said that “it’s definitely worth it for the price point” because of its high-quality fabric, and that it was great at regulating body temperature: “The texture and weight of this comforter definitely made a difference in my sleeping comfort,” she reported. Our testers didn’t have anything critical to say about this comforter, but some online reviewers noted that it became flat after they washed it.
Test Results: LinenSpa Down Alternative Comforter (Best Lightweight)
Lightweight but warm
Texture feels unnatural
Fabric holds wrinkles
“Honestly, I was very pleasantly surprised by the quality of this comforter for the price,” declared one of our testers. “It's not high end, but it does the job and was much less sweat inducing than my regular comforter. It was lightweight but still warm.” On the other hand, our reviewers noted that the fabric wrinkled easily and one reviewer thought that its material “felt too silky for my taste and almost slippery.”
Test Results: Superior Solid White Down Alternative Comforter (Best Down Alternative)
Lightweight but warm
Thick and fluffy
Not as breathable
One of our testers thought that this comforter was a “great hypoallergenic option” and was impressed with the “texture of the shell as well as the level of warmth delivered for the weight.” Our reviewers also loved its thickness and fluffiness. In terms of negatives, one tester thought its breathability was “a little lacking” and had concerns about the quality of the stitching: “The stitching on the shell seems looser than the double stitching around the edge,” she noted.