Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Yimby Tumbler Composter at Amazon
"Two-chamber design allows you to divvy up your compost."
Best Budget: Utopia Kitchen Stainless Steel Compost Bin at Amazon
"A great choice for its size, durability, and cost."
Best In-House Compost Bin: OXO Good Grips Easy Clean at Amazon
"Just what it says: Easy to clean."
Best Durability: Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin at Amazon
"Airtight sealed lid and stainless steel body."
Best Large: WC Redmon Green Culture Compost Bin at Amazon
"Can survive hot summers and frigid winters."
Best Odor-Fighting: Full Circle Fresh Air Compost Bin at Amazon
"Patented design lets air flow through."
Best for Chefs: Chef’n EcoCrock Counter Compost Bin at Amazon
"A great option for small kitchens."
01 of 07
Best Overall: Yimby Tumbler Composter
If you are a major composter, then having a unit outside is ideal for you. Yimbly's Tumbler Composter has a two-chamber design that allows you to divvy up your composting. You can use one side for fresh compost while the other side "cooks." This creates an uninterrupted flow, which is perfect for creating healthy and hearty compost.
This composter is designed to thrive outdoors. It is constructed with BPA free, UV inhibited recycled polypropylene and galvanized steel. The outside won’t be damaged by constant sunlight, which quickens the "cooking" process of compost to as little as two weeks. The tumbler design also aides in mixing your compost for a rich result.
With a 37-gallon capacity, the sky is the limit. If you have a big family, then filling it up every week will be easy. The composter boasts an adjustable air vent, which can help break up large clumps and mixes in an ample amount of oxygen, more than standard models.
02 of 07
Best Budget: Utopia Kitchen Stainless Steel Compost Bin
The Utopia Kitchen Stainless Steel Compost Bin is a great buy because of its size, durability and cost. This one has the capacity to hold 1.3 gallons of material. The 201-grade stainless steel prevents scratching, cracking and chipping that is common with other compost bins. It is still on the smaller side, but mighty.
The model also includes a charcoal filter to prevent any unwanted odors from lingering in your home due to the composting process and melding of materials inside. These features make it perfect for the kitchen.
The small capacity allows it to be portable and easy to carry and move around. It is also easy to lace around your home and can hold weeks’ worth of compost. It is easy to wash and clean between use with soap and water. The durable body lets you soak it to get rid of tougher remnants without any rusting.
03 of 07
Best In-House Compost Bin: OXO Good Grips Easy Clean Compost Bin
Keeping a compost bin in your home is easy (and smaller is perhaps better). You don’t want the compost sitting for weeks at a time in your home. The OXO Good Grips Easy Clean Compost Bin is just what it says: easy to clean. You can purchase it in black or white to fit your home aesthetics, so it doesn’t stick out like a sore thumb in your home.
The flip lid closes, but doesn't seal to prevent molding. But don’t worry, it still keeps your home odor free. The lack of seal actually allows a bit of oxygen to enter the compost bin, which prevents bacteria and mold from forming.
The smooth inner body also protects against gunky build-up that can happen if you’re mixing liquids and solids. The contoured bottom, removable lid and rotating handle make it super easy to empty and clean. However, it only holds about ¾ of a gallon, which could be a deal breaker for some.
04 of 07
Best Durability: Epica Stainless Steel Compost Bin
The airtight sealed lid and stainless steel body make this one-gallon compost bin from Epica a chic and modern addition to your home—most likely your kitchen. This bin is on the smaller side of most, so it’s ideal for keeping inside of your home.
It is made of premium rust-resistant, 304-grade stainless steel, so forget about rust, leakage and finger prints. For what it does, it’s a simple, yet attractive pail. Given that it fits one gallon of materials, it is small enough to conveniently store anywhere from your counter to under the sink.
This model also comes with a replaceable charcoal filter, which helps keep the contraption odor free. The filter is easy to clean, just use soap and water and it should last about six months. The carrying handle also makes it ideal to transport in and out of the house or around the kitchen.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Large: WC Redmon Green Culture Compost Bin
If you are getting into composting for the long run, then the WC Redmon Culture Compost Bin makes a great investment. It is made with high-impact, UV-protected rugged plastic resin and weighs about 15 pounds, so it can withstand various weather environments. It can survive through hot summers and rigid winters, so if you live in an area that experiences all four seasons, then this bin is perfect for you.
You can buy the compost bin alone or the compost bin with the aerator. The bin also gives you four door access and ventilation holes for maximum exposure to oxygen. It is the perfect place for both lawn and kitchen waste. If you’re a beginner, this composter comes with a DIY guide to assist in getting you started.
With the capability to hold 65 gallons of natural waste, this composter is not for the faint of heart. It is made for someone wanting to make the best out of composting and intends to stick with it.
06 of 07
Best Odor-Fighting: Full Circle Fresh Air Compost Bin
One major factor that goes into deciding whether or not to compost is odor. Of course, if you are letting waste decompose, there is going to be a smell associated with it. Luckily, many modern compost bins have features that aide in a completely odorless process, but this one takes extra measures to ensure it.
This model features a patented design that lets air flow through your compost much easier than a standard composter. It will cause a slower, gentler decomposition process and keeps your waste drier, reducing odors. It holds 1.5 gallons of waste, so this is perfect to have in family homes.
A great thing about this model is the cool, mod color scheme. The compost bins come in classic black and white, green slate and ruby red.
07 of 07
Best for Chefs: Chef’n EcoCrock Counter Compost Bin
If you are a chef or often cook multiple daily meals for your family, then a compost bin for your counter is a great way to cut down waste. The Chef’n EcoCrock Counter Compost Bin was made with personal use in mind. Its small, but it will let you collect up to three quarts of waste from your kitchen.
It's got an adorable stem-like handle on top, so it looks like an ordinary kitchen item. Clean up takes seconds, thanks to the inner bucket layer. This is a great option for small kitchens to get in on the composting system. You don’t need a huge outdoor composter to reduce waste. The plastic does not absorb odors or discolor over time.
This model also comes with two disposable natural charcoal filters to ensure your kitchen stays fresh when using your compost bin. If you want to remain as mess-free as possible, then you can insert a plastic liner inside to make disposal even easier.
Products Tested by The Spruce
How We Tested
We bought a top-rated compost bin that our reviewer tested for one year. We asked our tester to consider the most important features when using this bin, from its size to its setup process. We’ve outlined the key takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What To Look For in A Composter
The size of your household and how much you cook should determine how big your compost bin needs to be. You should also consider how often you’ll realistically have time to empty it and whether you want an indoor or outdoor model.
From basic models that simply store compost to those that will also “cook” it, compost bins offer a wide variety of features. For indoor options, add-ons like odor control are key while features like weatherproofing or durability may be more important if you plan to keep your compost bin outside. If you’re keeping it inside in a prominent place, you may also want to prioritize a bin’s style, so it doesn’t stick out in your home.
Ease of use
How much time and effort do you want to put into composting? If you’re looking for a simple way to cut down on waste, there are easy-to-use models that can help. If, however, you want one that takes care of yard waste and performs other duties, then you may need a bin that takes a bit more work on your part.
Test Results: Yimby Tumbler Composter (Best Overall)
What We Like
Breaks down food well
Keeps bugs out
What We Don't Like
Hard to assemble
Our reviewer loved the Yimby Tumbler Composter for its versatility, smart design, and attractive price point. "It's a really sharp looking composter. I actually think it looks pretty nice in the backyard," raved our tester. She also noted how it effectively kept bugs out despite having an easy-to-access door. However, our tester disliked the tricky setup process and the composter's smaller capacity.