The 7 Best Cotton Sheets of 2019

Outfit your bed with the most comfortable set for you

cotton sheets
@cannelle.olga / Twenty20
Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set at Brooklinen

“Free of harmful chemicals and made from high quality cotton.”

Best High-Thread Count: Mayfair Hotel Collection on Amazon

“Feels soft and luxurious.”

Best Lightweight: Mellanni Cotton Bed Sheets at Amazon

“These sheets are durable, breathable, and fade resistant.”

Best Value: AmazonBasics Sheet Set at Amazon

“The sateen finish adds a touch of luxe to your room.”

Best Organic: Cifelli OrganicPro Sheet Set at Amazon

“You know you’re buying a safe and ethical set.”

Best Return Policy: Casper Sheet Set at Target

“Noticeably soft and and stronger than traditional cotton.”

Best Egyptian Cotton: Pinzon 400-Thread Count Sheet Set at Amazon

“Customers praise the design and lightweight feel.”

  • 01 of 07

    Best Overall: Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set

    Luxe Core Sheet Set
    Courtesy of Brooklinen.

    Want to take your bedding up a notch? The Luxe Core Set by Brooklinen is hands down your best bet. From the shop that specializes in fine linens, you’d be hardpressed to find a site or review that doesn’t note these as one of the most luxe options around.

    The four piece set is made from a 480 thread count in a soft sateen weave for an ultra deluxe feel, which makes sense given that they’re part of their Premium Line. The ultra high quality sheets in this category are also slightly heavier than their original models since they’re constructed of long form cotton. Additionally, they’re Oeko-Tex® certified free of harmful chemicals, so while you rest away, you won’t have to worry about irritation.

  • 02 of 07

    Best High-Thread Count: Mayfair Linen Hotel Collection

    Very Good

    Get that hotel quality you love, right in your own home. This Mayfair selection is made from 100% Egyptian Cotton yarns to keep your comfort top of mind, even when you aren’t traveling! With an 800 thread count, they ensure super soft luxurious feels that’ll keep you at ease for all nights ahead. Thus, making them a runner-up in our cotton sheet round-up. 

    All our the brand’s sheets come with a four inch hem and are tailored with deep pockets to enhance your bedroom decor. Plus, they are designed with a breathable fabric that wicks away moisture to keep you cool through the night. Users claim they promote better airflow, although they do note they run a bit thin. Others say they are their most luxurious set yet, but callout to be weary of an initial offputting package scent.

    Regardless of which side the reviews fall, there is enough support behind them to make it clear that they’re popular among purchasers. Ready to give ‘em a try? Like the top choice, there’s also a 100% satisfaction guarantee here.

    Take a peek at some of the other best high-thread count bed sheets you can buy.

  • 03 of 07

    Best Lightweight: Mellanni 100% Cotton Bed Sheet Set

    Very Good

    This tops the list of best cotton sheets because it’s a dependable option that works well for a variety of needs. By nature, the Mellanni brand produces high-quality linens that are soft, yet safe for everyday use. In this case, the set offers luxurious comfort at a 300 thread-count. Plus there are a variety of other benefits too, including: durability, breathability and fade resistance. You can also wash these without worry. Simply add them to your machine on a cold gentle cycle, then tumble dry low. They’ll come out just as good as they did before they went in!

    Customers describe them as soft to the touch. One even said that they’re lightweight enough to be breathable for the summer, but not scratchy like most kinds of thin sheets. Another said they were incredibly affordable, noting that they had spent three times as much on sheets without the same qualities. Either way, the company offers an 100% money back guarantee, so trying them is risk-free.

  • 04 of 07

    Best Value: AmazonBasics 400 Thread Count Sheet Set

    When you’re buying for the guest room or second home, finding an affordable option is usually top of mind. Therefore, consider the AmazonBasics 400 Thread Count Sheet Set as a staple to add to your linen closet, or directly on the bed.

    Made of 100% cotton, the 400-thread-count sheet set offers breathability, reliable strength, and a wrinkle-free appearance. Plus, the sateen finish adds the touch of luxe your room is looking for. The neutral color palette coordinates with existing bedroom decor, while the decorative hem provides additional appeal.

    It’s hard to say no to a set that covers all of the basics. Scroll through the hundreds of customer reviews to see commentary that echoes this sentiment.

    Continue to 5 of 7 below.
  • 05 of 07

    Best Organic: Cifelli Home OrganicPro Cotton 6 Piece Queen Bed Sheet

    Rest easy knowing you’re sleeping on organic cotton. These Turkish-made sheets are fully certified in all three organic categories (re: cotton, dye, and fabrication environment) so you know you’re buying a safe and ethical set. Turkish Cotton is well known as a premium buy since it’s made with long staple fibers that are durable and soft. So, combined with an eco-friendly makeup and it’s hard to find a better set.

    One shopper said these were the only triple certified organic sheets she could find. While a rarity in the linen world, it’s even more noteworthy that the price doesn’t reflect this.Typically, sheets of this nature would run double the fee, but definitely not here!

    Take a peek at some of the other best organic bed sheets you can buy.

  • 06 of 07

    Best Return Policy: The Casper Sheet Set

    The Casper Sheet Set
    Courtesy of Target.

    Lately, there has been a lot of hype around Casper, the company that’s reimagining sleep. Now you can experience what everyone is raving about with their Pima Cotton set at one of your favorite discount retailers.

    What makes this item so noteworthy? The Pima Cotton used in Casper sheets comes from a farm in California’s Central Valley. This varietal is 35% longer and 45% stronger than traditional cottons, so it won’t wear easily. Plus, at a 400 thread count, it contains the noticeably soft exterior you love, without rips or tears occurring along the way.

    While it’s more of an investment piece, Casper is offering 100 nights to test it out in your home. So if you don’t love the quality it delivers, you can return it — no questions asked.

  • 07 of 07

    Best Egyptian Cotton: Pinzon 400-Thread-Count Egyptian Cotton Sateen Sheet Set

    Like to sleep under a soft, yet lightweight sheet? Then this set made with 100 percent Egyptian cotton is for you. Considered best in class when it comes to high-quality cotton, this 400 thread count option provides strength, softness, and sheen — consider it a trifecta of sorts.

    Customers have praised the design and how well it’s made. However, they do note that it doesn’t carry the cool, crisp feel some covet in their linens. If your heart is set on the Egyptian Cotton route, it’s hard to argue with a brand that has been providing stellar reviews and dependable products for several years.

Products Tested by

How We Tested

We bought three top-rated cotton sheet sets that our reviewers tested for 294 hours. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using these sheets, from weave to durability. We’ve outlined the key takeaways here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.

What to Look for in Cotton Sheets

Type Cotton sheets are known for being soft, breathable, and affordable. But if you want the best of the best, choose an extra-long staple cotton like Egyptian or Pima cotton, which are considered premium options.

Thread count A higher thread count isn’t always better, since thread count can be manipulated during the manufacturing process. Look for a thread count between 200 and 400 for the softest, most breathable cotton sheets.

Weave The majority of our picks fall under two weave options: percale and sateen. If you like lighter, crisper sheets, choose percale. If you prefer smooth and silky sheets, try sateen instead. Just note you’ll pay a premium for sateen, since it’s a more complicated weave.

Test Results: Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set (Best Overall)

Luxe Core Sheet Set
Courtesy of Brooklinen.

What We Like

  • Very soft

  • Fits well

  • Attractive design

What We Don't Like

  • Pricier

  • Limited color and pattern options

Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set
Brooklinen Sheet Set
Brooklinen Luxe Core

Our reviewers were overwhelmingly satisfied with the quality, softness, and design of these sheets: “They’re a wonderful choice and something you feel you’d have for a very long time,” one tester reported. Compared to other sheets, he said “they’re only getting softer with each use and are attractive when you make the bed. ” Although our testers didn’t have any negative things to say, a few reviewers at Brooklinen reported that the sheets felt itchy and ripped after the first wash. (Note, though, that Brooklinen sheets have a lifetime warranty — if they fray or tear, the company will repair or replace them free of charge.)

Test Results: Mayfair Linen Hotel Collection (Best High-Thread Count)

Very Good

What We Like

  • Crisp look and feel

  • Comfortable

  • Nice fit

What We Don't Like

  • Expensive

  • Actual color differs from online

Mayfair Linen Hotel Collection
Mayfair Hotel Collection
Mayfair Collection
Mayfair Linen
Mayfair Linen Hotel Collection sheets

Our testers found this set of sheets to be high quality and super comfortable. “Straight out of the package, they feel very thick, crisp, and cool to the touch — like a freshly made hotel bed,” one of our reviewers declared. After washing, the sheets maintained their crisp quality and also got even softer, according to our testers. One of our reviewers mentioned that she liked the color of the ivory sheet set, but it didn’t match the shade that was portrayed online. And while the sheets were thicker than less expensive sets one of our testers had purchased in the past, she felt the price was still a little steep.

Test Results: Mellanni 100% Cotton Bed Sheet Set (Best Lightweight)

Very Good

What We Like

  • Breathable

  • Very soft

  • Reasonably priced

What We Don't Like

  • Faint smell

  • Wrinkle easily

Mellanni 100% Cotton Bed Sheet Set
Mellanni Bed Sheet Set
Mellanni 100% Cotton Bed Sheet
Mellanni Bed Sheet
Mellanni sheets

Our reviewers loved how soft and breathable these sheets were. “I'm always looking for sheets that will be able to keep me at a comfortable body temperature throughout the night,” one of our testers explained, “[and] I didn't wake up overheated while using these sheets.” On the other hand, one of our reviewers said the sheets had a faint odor that didn’t completely go away after washing them. Overall, though, our testers thought the reasonable price and comfort level made this set a good buy.