Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Fun World Women's Peace Love Hippie Costume at Amazon
"The gold standard...classic (you can wear it again a few years from now), comfortable, modest, affordable."
"This gorgeous and mesmerizing shawl makes a statement way beyond what its price tag may suggest."
Straight from "The Handmaid's Tale"...comes in four sizes complete with a dress, cape, bonnet, and bag."
"Officially licensed by DC Comics, includes six pieces: a corset, a headpiece, a skirt, gauntlets, a belt, and a cape."
Best Last-Minute: Sidecca Metallic Mermaid Costume Maxi Skirt at Amazon
"Mermaid-shaped metallic skirt...four sizes; tail comes in green, hologram kelly, turquoise, hologram silver, or teal."
Most Comfortable: ES Unico Adult Animal Onesies Costumes at Amazon
"The one-piece suit is made of colorful and durable fleece to keep you warm all night long...choose this narwhal or any of 18 other options."
Best Classic: California Costumes Glamour Witch Costume at Amazon
"This black and purple costume...comes with a dress and a hat...comfortable and flattering."
"Attractive and impressive Halloween costume, structured dress and included headpiece...four sizes."
01 of 08
Best Overall: Fun World Women's Peace Love Hippie Costume
This getup probably won’t win any prizes at the Halloween costume contest, but it’s the gold standard when it comes to Halloween costumes. Why? It checks just about every box: It’s classic (you can wear it again a few years from now), it’s comfortable, it’s modest, and it’s affordable.
Plus, everything you need—from head to toe—is included. The costume comes with a dress complete with an attached vest, a headband, and boot covers. Totally groovy.
Dozens of reviewers note how many compliments they got about this costume. And why not? It’s true to size and looks great on.
If you live in a cool climate, throw some tights on for a little extra warmth. If you live in a warm climate, put the boot tassels on over flip-flops rather than boots.
02 of 08
Best Budget: VESNIBA Prop Soft Fabric Butterfly Wings Shawl
You don’t have to go all out on a costume to look fabulous on Halloween. In fact, some of the most creative costumes are born out of one simple accessory. And that’s exactly the idea here.
This gorgeous and mesmerizing shawl makes a statement way beyond what its price tag may suggest. Choose from 30 different color combinations and patterns, and simply throw it on over a black dress to transform yourself into a beautiful butterfly for the evening.
Reviewers note that the design is realistic and that it’s the perfect costume for accompanying kids while they trick-or-treat. It’s not too fussy, but it doesn’t look like you phoned it in either.
03 of 08
Best Trendy: Halloween Party Online Adult Women's Handmaid Full Set Costume
If you’re looking for a trendy Halloween costume, look no further. This costume comes straight from the scenes of one of the most popular —and disturbing—shows on television, The Handmaid's Tale.
You may not be able to stroll through Gilead (consider that a good thing!), but you can take the kids trick-or-treating or hit the local Halloween parade in this four-piece getup. Each set, available in four sizes, comes complete with a dress, a cape, a bonnet, and a bag. Reviewers note the costume is a bit long, but otherwise fits true to size.
04 of 08
Best Sexy: Secret Wishes DC Comics Wonder Woman Corset Costume
What’s sexier than a strong, independent woman? This Halloween costume is a great choice for someone who wants to look sexy without showing too much skin.
The costume, which is officially licensed by DC Comics, includes six pieces: a corset, a headpiece, a skirt, gauntlets, a belt, and a cape. Choose from four sizes: extra-small (0-2), small (2-6), medium (6-10), and large (10-14).
Reviewers recommend considering bust size before ordering and sizing up if you have a larger chest, but otherwise say the costume fits nicely and is well-made.Continue to 5 of 8 below.
05 of 08
Best Last-Minute: Sidecca Metallic Mermaid Costume Maxi Skirt
What do you do when the party is in two days and you still don’t have a costume? Buying a single item and piecing the rest together with things you already own can be a great solution.
This mermaid-shaped metallic skirt is exactly what you need to transform yourself into a mermaid for the night. Simply choose your favorite color mermaid tail (green, hologram kelly, turquoise, hologram silver, or teal) and pair it with a brightly colored bathing suit top or T-shirt. Bonus points for some creative face makeup.
The costume is available in four sizes (small through extra-large), but reviewers note the stretchy nature of the costume offers some forgiveness in sizing.
06 of 08
Most Comfortable: ES Unico Adult Animal Onesies Costumes
A unicorn is one costume that’s all but guaranteed to be everywhere again this year. Stand out from all the other unicorns by being a narwhal—the unicorn of the sea—instead.
This costume is not only more unique than the alternative, but it’s also a truly comfortable disguise, particularly if you live in a chillier climate. The one-piece suit is made of colorful and durable fleece to keep you warm all night long.
If a narwhal isn’t your thing, choose from 18 other options, from a cow or a koala bear to a pug or a corgi.
07 of 08
Best Classic: California Costumes Women's Incantasia, The Glamour Witch Costume
One of the most classic Halloween looks gets a sophisticated upgrade. Slip this black and purple costume on and—like magic— you’ll be transformed into a witch for the night.
Each package comes with a dress and a hat— it’s up to you to add shoes and a broom to complete the costume. The pointed hat has a decorative buckle and the long-sleeve dress features a contrasting sash and a standing collar.
Reviewers praise the costume for being comfortable, flattering, appropriate, and well-made.
08 of 08
Best Scary: Women's Disney Maleficent Black Christening Gown Costume
Sometimes it seems like finding an attractive and impressive Halloween costume at an affordable price is an impossible feat, but this costume proves otherwise. The structured dress and included headpiece looks upscale enough for a Halloween gala but suits an afternoon trick-or-treating session with the kids just as well.
The officially licensed costume comes in four sizes: small, medium, large, and extra-large. Most reviewers note the sizing is accurate and the dress fits well. Others note the headpiece is attached to a piece of cardboard that helps keep it in place.
If there is one, the only drawback is the fabric may arrive slightly wrinkled—but that’s nothing an iron can’t fix!