The 9 Best Innerspring Mattresses of 2023

Best Overall

Boll & Branch The Mattress

4.8

View On Bollandbranch.com

Boll & Branch offers one mattress and one mattress only—because it's that good. The Mattress earned a 4.8 out of 5 overall score during our home testing. We loved the supportive yet soft design and luxuriously comfortable wool shell. We also appreciated its temperature-regulating layers, which kept us comfortable all night. Thanks to multiple layers of naturally breathable, moisture-wicking, and temperature-regulating materials, like wool and graphite-infused latex, we fell asleep and stayed asleep more easily.

Unlike the innerspring mattresses of decades past, this one boasts individually wrapped foundation coils, plus over 2,000 encased micro-coils to offer full-body support and isolate movement. In our testing, we found that the springs do a great job preventing motion transfer; however, we also noted that they make a little noise when climbing on the bed and with excessive movement. The natural latex and graphite-infused latex layers are both natural foam alternatives to the popular memory foam models from mattress-in-a-box brands.

Coils on the head and foot of the mattress offer greater support for your neck, shoulders, ankles, and feet, while larger coils offer firm support along your back. The Mattress is hand-assembled from ethically sourced, sustainable materials and backed by a ten-year warranty. Boll & Branch offers a 100-night sleep trial so you can be sure The Mattress is the right fit for you. While the price is pretty steep, we think this mattress' construction, quality, and comfort make it a worthy investment.

Price at time of publish: $1,900 for Twin

_{Material: Steel coils, wool-poly blend, graphite-infused latex | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal. king | Thickness: 13.5 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best Budget

Swiss Ortho Sleep Encased Coil Pocket Spring Contour Mattress

View On Amazon

Looking for something a little easier on your bank account? Check out the Swiss Ortho Sleep Encased Coil Pocket Spring Contour Mattress. It's 12 inches thick (a 10-inch thickness is also available) with a foundation of individually wrapped pocket springs, offering support and stability, while isolating movement. You'll no longer have to worry about disturbing your sleeping partner when you climb in bed. The springs also offer edge support, which prevents you from feeling like you could roll off the bed.

The upper layers consist of a cotton pad, 1-inch-thick wave foam, half an inch of memory foam, and bamboo fabric. As an inherently breathable material with natural temperature-regulating abilities, the bamboo helps you stay at a comfy temperature throughout the night. While it's unavailable in a twin XL size, unlike many other innerspring models, this mattress comes in compressed packaging, making it easier to move into your room of choice. However, you will have to allow this mattress to fully expand for up to 72 hours before you can sleep on it. Most mattresses that come in a box are ready to go in just 24 hours, but don't be surprised if you notice more expansion after that period.

Price at time of publish: $330 for 12-inch Queen

_{Material: Coils, foam, cotton, memory foam, bamboo fabric | Sizes: Twin, full, queen, king, Cal king | Thickness: 12 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best Splurge

Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Cassatt Mattress

View On Amazon View On Pottery Barn View On Macy's

If you're looking for a plus mattress that's still firm and luxuriously crafted, consider the Lux Estate Cassatt from Stearns & Foster. This mattress is available in a number of firmness levels (plush to extra firm), and it has a ventilated coil system at the base to ensure breathability and temperature regulation. Extra vents on the outside of the mattress base also ensure that stale air is never trapped within the coil system. The two types of densely packed, individually wrapped IntelliCoil innersprings promise adaptive comfort for all types of sleepers and edge support, so you won't have to worry about the mattress losing its shape over time.

The Lux Estate mattress comes with extra TEMPUR-Indulge Memory Foam, compared to the standard Estate mattress, giving the Lux even more enhanced pressure relief. The quilted cover is made from TENCEL, a sustainably sourced material with a silky feel that helps wick away sweat while you snooze. The only potential downside of this mattress is that you'll need to purchase an extra-deep fitted sheet, since it's thicker than average at 15 inches deep. You can also choose a pillow top finish for an even plusher sleep experience.

Price at time of publish: $2,349 for Luxury Firm top, Queen

_{Material: Encased coils, Tempur-Pedic memory foam, TENCEL | Sizes: Twin, queen, king, Cal. king, split king, split Cal. king | Thickness: 13, 14.5, and 15 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best Firm

Allswell The Brick Mattress

View On Walmart View On Allswellhome.com

The Allswell Brick Mattress is an even firmer version of the brand's luxe hybrid mattress. In a nod to its name, this mattress offers firmness without being overly hard or uncomfortable. It has a base of individually wrapped coils that help to minimize motion transfer and offer edge support on all sides to prevent you from sinking in when you sit down or roll to an edge.

A 2-inch layer of high-density foam offers additional support and the top 1-inch, copper-infused memory foam layer helps move heat away from the body for a cooler sleep. The minimally padded top layer results in a firm finish that doesn't result in that overwhelming sinking feeling that some pillow top mattresses have. This mattress arrives compressed in a box, making it easy to carry to your bedroom, but it takes about a day to expand fully. While an extra-firm mattress may not be for everyone, back and stomach sleepers with joint pain may find relief in this mattress that offers maximum support at all times.

Price at time of publish: $399 for Twin

_{Material: Coils, high-density foam, copper-infused memory foam | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal. king | Thickness: 12 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best Pillow-Top

Saatva Classic Mattress

4.2

View On Saatva

Saatva's Classic Mattress clocked a 4.8 out of 5 overall score during our in-home testing. We liked the responsive comfort of the coils and the thoughtful design behind it. When ordering, you can choose from two thicknesses (11.5 or 14.5 inches) and three firmness levels: plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. This mattress took about two weeks to arrive at our home, but we were happy to wait for our made-to-order mattress to arrive in pristine condition.

Although we were initially disappointed by the plush soft mattress's lack of cushy softness, we found that it started to learn our movements with each night of sleep and become more comfortable with regular use. This mattress has a dual-coil base with a high-density foam rail around the entire edge to prevent sagging. Responsive Lumbar Zone Pocketed Coils are located in the center third of this mattress to support where most of your body weight is concentrated. This is also the layer that "responds" to movement, which we felt during our five-week test. Just above, CertiPUR-US certified high-density memory foam offers pressure point relief, and the organic cotton cover is naturally hypoallergenic to promote a healthier sleep.

We did discover that this mattress does not isolate movement, which can be especially frustrating if you have a restless sleeping partner. There's also a fee if you return it, but you can't beat the lifetime warranty that promises protection for your mattress at every stage of its lifetime.

Price at time of publish: $1,995 for Queen

_{Material: Steel pocketed coils, memory foam, organic cotton | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, Cal. king, split Cal. king | Thickness: 11.5 or 14.5 inches | Warranty: Lifetime}

Best for Back Sleepers

Serta Perfect Sleeper Firm Innerspring Mattress

View On Amazon View On Macy's View On Serta.com

All back sleepers understand the frustration of trying to find a mattress that supports their hips while also aligning their shoulders and feet. Enter: Serta's Perfect Sleeper Mattress. This firm hybrid mattress features 1,000 densely packed, individually wrapped metal coils to minimize motion transfer and ensure support from head to heel. You can choose among three support levels—standard, enhanced, and ultimate—which increase in the number of supportive layers as you increase in level. The Perfect Sleeper is also available in plush, medium, and extra-firm feels, all of which can also be purchased in a pillow top finish.

If you purchase the Ultimate level, coined the "Luminous Sleep" by Serta, you can expect three different memory foam layers that offer pressure relief, a cooling sensation, and cushioned support where you need it. The BubbleCloud Memory Foam layer, a pillow-peaked foam meant to deliver cushioning support, is what sets the ultimate level apart from the enhanced level. No matter the level of the Perfect Sleeper you purchase, the top of the mattress is covered in CoolFeel fabric, which is plant-derived and feels cool to the touch. Though this mattress might be too firm for folks who sleep on their sides, it's ideal for those who doze on their backs with minimal tossing and turning.

Price at time of publish: $699 for Queen

_{Material: Coils, gel-infused memory foam | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal. king | Thickness: 14 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best for Side Sleepers

Parachute Eco Comfort Mattress

View On Parachute

If you're part of the 60 percent of people who sleep on their sides, Parachute's Eco Comfort Mattress has your name on it. The medium-firm design consists of several layers, starting with an insulator wool pad on the bottom, which protects your bed frame from the pocket coils. Two types of pocketed innerspring coils offer different levels of support for your upper body, hips, and feet. The Comfort Zone 1 soft coils at your shoulders and feet allow your spine to fall into proper alignment with the Support Zone firm coils located in the middle of the mattress.

The mid wool insulator pad protects the microcoils from the pocketed coils below, and the three tiers of tiny microcoils react individually to isolate movement and conform to the shape of your body. Atop these layers is one more wool pad to help regulate your body temperature, and a quilted organic cotton shell rounds out the mattress design. Side sleepers will find their shoulder pains alleviated, and their legs will easily align with their spine for a comfortable sleeping position all night.

Aside from this mattress's comfortable design, we appreciate its thoughtful craftsmanship. The Eco Comfort Mattress is completely recyclable and sustainable for the environment—free from toxic chemicals like chemical flame retardants, foams, or adhesives. There's a lot to love about this thoughtfully designed mattress, but we do wish it were more affordable. However, we recognize that the price is justified by the high-quality materials and thoughtful design. We also recommend having a second person nearby to help unbox this mattress, as it could be quite heavy.

Price at time of publish: $2,399 for Queen

_{Material: Coils, organic cotton, wool | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal. king | Thickness: 13 inches | Warranty: 10 years}

Best for Stomach Sleepers

Avocado Green Mattress

5

View On Avocadogreenmattress.com

Avocado's Green Mattress is a supportive option to consider if you sleep on your stomach. It has over 1,400 fabric-wrapped tempered steel coils, and the springs are arranged in five different zones to provide ergonomic support in all the right places. A reinforced steel perimeter, which prevents you from sinking down when you sit or sleep on a side, wraps around the mattress. The multiple zones of coils ensures that the mattress responds to your movement, keeps your back aligned, and alleviates pressure points. This is key for stomach sleepers who need extra support to keep their back and hips aligned.

Above the coils sit 3 inches of GOLS organic certified latex rubber to provide full-body support with medium firmness. You also have the option to purchase this mattress with a pillow top (an additional 2 inches of latex rubber foam) for even more pressure relief, which is ideal for combination sleepers. The outer shell is tufted wool that's not only organic but also Oeko-Tex certified to ensure it's safe for you and the planet. Like most organic mattresses, this model comes at a heftier price tag, but we expect that for such high quality. If you're a side sleeper, we recommend checking out the pillow top mattress, which will offer more support to your hips and shoulder while you're on your side.

Price at time of publish: $1,999 for Standard Queen

_{Material: Coils, natural latex, organic wool, organic cotton | Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, Cal. king | Thickness: 11 or 13 inches | Warranty: 25 years}