The 8 Best Key Holders to Buy in 2018

Organize the chaos with these top-picks

Umbra-Yook

Courtesy of ContainerStore 

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Our Top Picks

Best Overall: mDesign Mail, Letter Holder, Key Rack Organizer at Amazon

"Comes in five different finishes...It has five hooks so it can hold five sets of keys and it also has room to store the day's mail."

Best Budget: Umbra Yook Key Hook & Organizer at The Container Store

"The slim metal key holder features four rubberized hooks that fit keys, scarves, dog leashes, or other small accessories."

Best for Letters and Keys: Umbra Magnetic Key/Mail Organizer at Amazon

"The design is slightly curved off the wall to accommodate an area made especially for tucking mail or other important papers within reach."

Best Personalized: Riverside Bridal Personalized Key Holder at Etsy

"Features a place for his and her keys, a set of house keys, as well as a designated spot for the family pet’s leash, but other designs are available."

Best for Apartments: InterDesign York Self-Adhesive Key Rack at Amazon

"Can accommodate up to four pairs of keys, leashes, or other small lightweight items."

Best Rustic: Wildon Home Metal Wall Organizer at Wayfair

"Can not only hold your keys—it can also stash mail, important papers, and much more."

Best Removable: Command Key Rail at Amazon

"Has four hooks on it so it can hold plenty of sets. When it is time to move you can easily remove this without doing any damage to the walls."

Best With Chalkboard: Kate and Laurel Stallard Organizer at Wayfair

"Has three hooks with six prongs total for keys, three mail slots, and plenty of space to write whatever you need to communicate."

  • 01 of 08

    Best Overall: mDesign Mail, Letter Holder, Key Rack Organizer

    If your looking for something that is not only affordable, but practical, and can blend in seamlessly to your decor this organizer is just the thing. This Amazon Choice comes in five different finishes so you are bound to find something that works for you. It has five hooks so it can hold five sets of keys and it also has room to store the day's mail. 

    Reviewers love that this is functional and designed well. Many have said after they installed it they no longer lose their keys or important mail so this can help get a busy household organized in no time. 

  • 02 of 08

    Best Budget: Umbra Yook White Key Hook & Organizer

    Umbra-Yook

    Courtesy of ContainerStore 

    When you don’t need anything fancy — just a place to stash a set of keys — an inexpensive, no-frills pick like this one is more than sufficient.

    The slim metal key holder features four rubberized hooks that fit keys, scarves, dog leashes, or other small accessories. It also has a built-in catchall above the hooks where you can conveniently stash sunglasses, change, mail and papers, or other small items.

    The unit mounts to the wall easily with included hardware.

  • 03 of 08

    Best for Letters and Keys: Umbra Magnetter Magnetic Key/Mail Organizer

    In this case, sleek and streamlined doesn’t equate to functionality. This wooden key holder uses strong magnets, rather than hooks, to keep three sets of keys (even heavy keys like car keys with remotes) corralled when not in use. The design is slightly curved off the wall to accommodate an area made especially for tucking mail or other important papers within reach of the front or back door.

    The unit is available in two finishes — espresso and white — and comes with hidden mounting hardware for easy installation.

    More than 200 reviewers give this key holder five stars, citing the modern look, the strong and functional magnets, and the durability (one reviewer said the unit had no scratches after a year of use!).

  • 04 of 08

    Best Personalized: Riverside Bridal Personalized Key Holder

    Riverside

    Courtesy of Etsy 

    Consider this the easiest and most functional way to spruce up your entryway. This wooden wall mount key holder features four silver hooks, black beveled edges, and personalization that won’t chip or peel over time (the image is not a vinyl decal—it’s printed right onto the wood).

    This particular design features a place for his and her keys, a set of house keys, as well as a designated spot for the family pet’s leash, but other designs are available. If you prefer, choose a simple family name, a design that features your home state, or one for a beach house, cabin, or farm house.

    Reviewers note excellent quality and fast shipping.

    Continue to 5 of 8 below.
  • 05 of 08

    Best for Apartments: InterDesign York Self-Adhesive Key Rack

    Renters will delight in the fact that this key rack doesn’t require any permanent mounting — it sticks to the wall with self-adhesive backing. Despite that, this key holder can accommodate up to four pairs of keys, leashes, or other small lightweight items.

    Sound too good to be true? Reviewers say otherwise, with one noting his key holder stood up to heavy use for over a year. Other reviewers have had their key holder for several years without problems.

    Choose from two sizes — small or medium — and three colors — bronze, chrome, or white.

  • 06 of 08

    Best Rustic: Wildon Home Metal Wall Organizer

    wildon-home-organizer

    Courtesy of Wayfair

    Get your Chip and Joanna Gaines on with this rustic metal wall organizer that can not only hold your keys—it can also stash mail, important papers, and much more. Hang this up at the front door to help you keep your entryway tidy or use it in the kitchen as a family command center. No matter where you use this, it will get good use and add a decorative touch to the wall. 

    Reviewers agree that this organizer is the perfect size with many people using it all over the house including the garage, laundry room,  and even small apartments. 

  • 07 of 08

    Best Removable: Command Key Rail

    If you don't want to put holes into your wall you might want to try this pick from Command which sticks to the wall with their patent-pending strips that will hold up to two pounds. This rail has four hooks on it so it can hold plenty of sets. When it is time to move you can easily remove this without doing any damage to the walls which makes it a smart buy for renters.

    Many reviewers say they've installed multiples of these throughout the house because they not only work great for keys they are also good for dog leashes, necklaces and more. 

  • 08 of 08

    Best With Chalkboard: Kate and Laurel Stallard Organizer Chalkboard

    chalkboard-wall-organizer

    Courtesy of Wayfair

    Want to have the option to leave important messages for your family? Then you'll want a key holder that also has a memo or chalkboard. This pretty pick has three hooks with six prongs total for keys, three mail slots, and plenty of space to write whatever you need to communicate. 

    This choice gets top reviews from the buyer's saying this has everything they need to stay organized and on top of the comings and goings at home. For those who live in small spaces, they say this blends in nicely into their living room without looking out of place. 

Disclosure

At The Spruce, our Expert writers are committed to researching and writing thoughtful and editorially independent reviews of the best products for your life and your family. If you like what we do, you can support us through our chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn more about our review process.