Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Queen Size Quilted Mattress Pad at Amazon
“Provides cushy comfort and a hypoallergenic fill.”
Runner Up, Best Overall: All Season Alternative Mattress Topper at Amazon
“A great choice for more cushioning.”
Best Value: Utopia Bedding Mattress Pad at Amazon
“Stays in place thanks to a Smooth Grip Skirt System.”
Best for Allergy Sufferers: SafeRest Mattress Protector at Amazon
“Protects your bed from allergens and liquids.”
Best Waterproof: Hanna Kay Waterproof Mattress Protector at Amazon
“Keeps fluids from spills and accidents from ruining the mattress.”
Best for Pest Protection: Sleep Defense Mattress Encasement at Amazon
“Specifically designed to be 100 percent bed bug-proof.”
Best for Kids: American Baby Company Mattress Cover at Amazon
“Protects the mattress from fluids.”
01 of 07
Best Overall: Queen Size Hypoallergenic Quilted Stretch-to-Fit Mattress Pad
A number one bestseller in its category, this quilted mattress pad provides cushy comfort and a hypoallergenic fill and is great for allergy sufferers. It has knitted sides that stretch to fit mattresses up to 18 inches deep without worrying about rips or tears. Made of breathable poly-cotton, it’s machine-washable and can go in the dryer as well. The mattress pad is also backed by a 10-year warranty.
The majority of customers give it five stars for overall quality. One reviewer who suffered from bad allergies before buying the mattress pad said that since getting this, they haven’t sneezed as much in bed and can breathe better at night. Many say it’s a great value for the price. In terms of critical reviews, one customer said it isn’t as cushioned as they were hoping. So if you’re looking for a mattress pad to add a plush layer to your bed, this might not be the right pick.
02 of 07
Runner Up, Best Overall: All Season Down Alternative Queen Mattress Topper
If you’re looking for extra comfort, a down alternative mattress pad is a great choice for more cushioning. This mattress pad includes two inches of memory foam and microfiber fill, along with a comfy microfiber cover. It’s machine washable, although some customers have had issues after running it through the washer and dryer.
The majority of customers have been satisfied with the mattress cover. One said it turns a boring bed into a comfy pillow top. Another said it gave them the best night’s sleep they’ve ever had thanks to the plush feeling. Overall, customers were happy with the performance of this mattress pad.
03 of 07
Best Value: Utopia Bedding Quilted Fitted Mattress Pad
Understandably, many buyers don’t want to spend a lot on an out-of-sight, out-of-mind product like a mattress pad. The Utopia Bedding Quilted Fitted Mattress Pad proves you don’t have to, but can still get a quality product. It covers the top and sides of mattresses up to 16 inches thick. The top is brushed microfiber, and inside the diamond-stitch quilting is high-loft polyester fiberfill. It’s also hypoallergenic, so allergy sufferers can sleep easy.
Though some reviewers are disappointed that it’s not waterproof, most say this Utopia pad provides good bang for their buck and rarely slips once it’s in place thanks to a Smooth Grip Skirt System. They like that it can be machine washed and dried, too – just be sure to follow instructions, which recommend the gentle washing cycle and lowest dryer temperature. The pad is available for all major mattress sizes: twin, extra-long twin, full, queen, king and California king.
04 of 07
Best for Allergy Sufferers: SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector
If you or your kids have bad allergies, you’ll want a mattress pad that is hypoallergenic, protecting against dust mites and other allergens. You’ll also want to look for one that is vinyl-free (which this one is) since that can cause allergies to flare up as well.
Available in all sizes from twin to California king, this mattress pad is made from hypoallergenic cotton and has a coating on the back that protects your bed from allergens and liquids. So no need to worry about accidents or spills from those Saturday morning breakfasts in bed. The sides are connected with an elastic band to be sure the mattress pad stays firmly in place—you won’t even notice it underneath your sheets. It can be machine washed and dried, but don’t use products that contain bleach for the best results. You can also rest assured knowing that it’s backed by a 10-year warranty.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Waterproof: Hanna Kay Premium 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector
Made with a thin membrane of polyurethane, this mattress pad is 100 percent waterproof, but won’t crinkle or crack loudly as you’re crawling into bed thanks to its sturdy construction. It’s also good for people who have allergies, asthma, or eczema since it traps allergens on the surface making them easy to wash away. The pad is also breathable and can be washed and dried in your washing machine. It can fit any mattress depth from 6 inches to 18 inches and includes a 10-year warranty.
Most customers who have purchased this product have been satisfied with it. Many have said the fit is great and it keeps fluids from spills and accidents from ruining the mattress. Others have raved about the silence of the mattress pad when you move around on it and the fact that it doesn’t raise the temperature of your bed while you’re sleeping. In terms of negative reviews, some have had issues with leaks into the mattress, but most people have been happy with its performance.
06 of 07
Best for Pest Protection: Sleep Defense System Bed Bug Proof Mattress Encasement
Worried about the creepy crawlies getting into your bed? This mattress pad is specifically designed to be 100 percent bed bug-proof. This zippered cover can stretch to fit any mattress depth from 12 to 18 inches, completely encasing your mattress to keep the bugs out. Made of a high thread-count polyester knit fabric and a polyurethane waterproof layer, it’s designed to repel small liquid spills and can also ease asthma symptoms by blocking allergens as you sleep. You can machine wash and dry this product, and it comes with a five-year limited warranty.
Those who have this mattress pad in their home have been mostly happy with the product. Some reviewers who had bed bugs before buying it say it brought comfort and peace of mind to their sleep at night. Most negative reviews were those unsatisfied with how this product held up over time. A couple of those with major bed bug infestations still had issues with bugs in the bed. But the majority of those who used it for bed bug protection would recommend it to others.
07 of 07
Best for Kids: American Baby Company Waterproof Fitted Mattress Cover
Looking for a mattress protector for your child’s crib or bed? This one from American Baby Company is a great choice. Made to fit crib mattresses or toddler beds, it’s constructed from 100 percent polyester with waterproof vinyl in the middle layer, which protects the mattress from fluids. It also has elastic all around the edges, which means it hugs the mattress and won’t shift no matter how much your little one moves around in their sleep. The mattress pad can be washed and dried in the machine.
The majority of customers would recommend this product to others. One said that even though it’s waterproof, it doesn’t make a crinkling sound when the baby moves around on it. Another said that it works well in terms of its waterproof effectiveness. A few customers have mentioned that they had issues with it holding up in the wash. But most were happy with their purchase.
How We Tested
Our reviewers spent over 200 hours testing two of the top-rated mattress pads available.To really get the full experience, they slept on them nightly for weeks on end. We asked our testers to consider the most important features when using these mattress pads, from their material to their comfort level. We've outlined them here so that you, too, know what to look for when shopping.
What to Look for in a Mattress Pad
Material Choose a mattress pad material that makes sense for your season and your situation. Cotton or poly-cotton mattress pads will offer breathability and are usually the most budget-friendly options. More specialized materials, like down or wool, can offer warmth in the winter but are also adaptable in hotter weather. Check to see whether or not the mattress pad is machine washable and be on the lookout for any potential allergy triggers if you’re sensitive to things like vinyl.
Depth Avoid the hassle and frustration of trying to stretch a too-small mattress pad over your mattress by making sure that it’s deep enough for your bed. While standard mattresses should pose no problem, if you have a deep or extra deep mattress, you’ll want to find a pad that can accommodate that. Most mattress pads have super stretchy sides and corners to fit a range of mattress depths, but it pays to double check this measurement before picking one.
Special Features Some mattress pads do more than just provide a layer of protection between you and your mattress. There are hypoallergenic mattress pads that guard against dust mites and other allergy triggers that may be lurking in your bed. Waterproof mattress pads will keep spills or leaks from seeping through to the bed below — just be sure to choose one that isn’t so crinkly that it becomes uncomfortable. Finally, bed bug mattress pads put your bed on lockdown and prevent bed bugs from entering. (This type of specialized mattress pad offers protection on all six sides of your mattress.)
Test Results: Queen Size Hypoallergenic Quilted Stretch-to-Fit Mattress Pad (Best Overall)
What We Like
What We Don't Like
“This is a perfect value mattress pad,” declared one of our testers. In particular, our reviewers found it to be budget friendly and durable, and one person reported that it helped regulate her body temperature while sleeping: “My body heat definitely rises when I sleep,” she explained, “and I feel like this helped me sweat a little less.” On the other hand, our testers felt this pad was a little too thin to affect comfort in a major way. They also wished it was waterproof.
Test Results: All Season Down Alternative Queen Mattress Topper (Runner Up, Best Overall)
What We Like
Convenient to take on and off
What We Don't Like
Flattens over time
Doesn’t stay in place
Our testers recommended this product as a good option for a mattress that doesn’t need a ton of extra padding. Our reviewers loved the fact that it was so lightweight and didn’t get hot during the night. According to our testers, the mattress pad was also super convenient: “It was easy to put on the bed because it didn't have pockets to go on the mattress,” one of our reviewers explained. However, she noted that this also meant the pad would shift during sleep and need to be readjusted. “It kind of goes flat after a while,” commented one of our testers, warning that if you’re looking for a super fluffy pad, this wasn’t your best bet.