The Best Mattress Protectors to Keep Your Mattress in Tip-Top Shape

Best Overall: Parachute Cotton Mattress Protector

5

View On Parachute

In terms of features and value, it's hard to beat the Parachute Cotton Mattress Protector. Made of 100% cotton, it has a soft and comfortable feel that will also keep you cool as you sleep. Plus, the top layer is quilted to provide extra cushioning—something that's hard to find in a mattress protector.

Parachute's mattress protector is available in a variety of sizes and can accommodate mattresses up to 16 inches thick. It can be tossed in a standard washing machine with the rest of your bedding, so you can keep everything fresh and clean.

One note is that this option doesn't have a waterproof barrier. If you find that your mattress needs protection from spills, kids, or pets, you should layer it with another waterproof product.

Best Budget: Utopia Bedding Waterproof Mattress Encasement

View On Amazon

To protect your mattress without spending a lot of money, consider the Utopia Bedding Zipped Mattress Encasement. It provides a waterproof barrier and zips to cover the entire mattress—even the back. In case of a spill or accident, simply toss it in the wash and tumble dry. Because it's sold in a two-pack, you'll always have a spare on hand.

It is made of polyester, so expect things to be a little bit hotter than with other options. The zippered enclosure can also be tricky to maneuver on larger beds, making it a better option for kids' or twin-sized mattresses.

Best Waterproof : SafeRest Premium Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector

5

View On Amazon View On Walmart

This vinyl-free mattress protector from SafeRest is a great option that provides a waterproof barrier without changing the feel of your mattress (or using any materials known to bother sleepers). With a fitted design, all you need to do is put it underneath your fitted sheet to know that your mattress is protected. If it does get soiled, simply toss it in your washer with the rest of your bedding.

With no extra cushioning or support, this protector may feel more like a sheet than a mattress pad. However, if you're just looking for a waterproof barrier, it's one of the better options. It passed our spill test in The Lab, keeping the mattress fully protected from liquids.

Best Organic: Coyuchi Organic Mattress Pad

4.5

View On Coyuchi.com

Coyuchi's Organic Mattress Pad is a high-quality option that comes at a premium price. Both the interior and exterior are made of 100% organic cotton, which is ethically sourced in India. The mattress pad is also GOTS and Made Safe certified, so it's free of potentially harmful substances like flame retardants or heavy metals.

Suitable for mattresses up to 15 inches deep, the Organic Mattress Pad has a quilted top layer that provides a soft, cushiony feel. It isn't advertised as waterproof, but it provides enough protection from spills or accidents if cleaned up immediately. When testing it in The Lab, we were impressed with how well it absorbed liquid without letting it touch the mattress. And when laundry day does roll around, you can toss it in your washing machine with like colors.

Best Long-Lasting: Avocado Organic Cotton Mattress Pad Protector

4

View On Avocadogreenmattress.com

Another organic cotton option, the Avocado Organic Cotton Mattress Pad Protector is made by hand, quilted with reinforced edges, and comes in two depth options. While expensive, the materials are some of the best you can get—when testing it in The Lab, we were wowed by the silky, cooling fabric and virtual undetectability underneath a fitted sheet. It also has the most certifications of any on our list, so you know that you’re getting a superior product from a company that really cares.

The mattress pad isn’t completely waterproof and is quite pricey—even more than some mattresses. If you want a mattress pad for short-term use, it probably isn’t worth the cost. But if you want something that will last and keep you comfortable for years, the organic mattress protector from Avocado is great.

Best Cushioning: The Company Store Legends Hotel Waterproof Mattress Pad

View On Thecompanystore.com

Just because you want to protect your mattress doesn't mean you need to sacrifice comfort. Case in point: The Company Store's Legends Hotel Waterproof Mattress Pad. With a diamond-quilted shell and a padded waterproof layer, it provides all the protection and cushioning you could need. It's available in two heights—11 or 18 inches—and six sizes, so you'll be sure to find the perfect fit for your mattress.

While one of the pricier options on our list, this mattress protector is cheaper than buying a waterproof layer and mattress pad separately. Plus, it's machine-washable, which can be hard to find in a cushioned pad.

Best Cooling: Casper Waterproof Mattress Protector

View On Casper

Casper mattresses are top quality, so it’s no surprise that their mattress protector options are also highly-rated. The brand's waterproof mattress protector uses a crinkle-free polyester with a barrier to keep your mattress safe from spills or accidents without disturbing your sleep. While polyester can be hot, this protector is designed with microscopic pores to allow heat to escape so that you stay cool.

There isn’t any added cushion with this mattress protector, but it can be easily layered with a mattress pad of your choice. Just note that it's designed to work best with Casper mattresses.