The 9 Best Doormats of 2023, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

Entryways Coir Rope Knot Doormat

4.7

View On Amazon View On Walmart View On Food52

Our Ratings

• Quality
  5/5
• Durability
  4/5
• Value
  5/5
• Design
  5/5
• Effectiveness
  4.5/5

When it comes to outdoor doormats, coir (pronounced COY-er) is the gold standard, for good reason. Made from coconut husks, it's thick and scratchy, so it's a good material for getting gunk, including snow, off shoes. It also absorbs moisture, so you don't track footprints into the house.

Out of all of the doormats we tested, our top choice is the Food52 Coir Rope Doormat. It lived up to the advantages of a coir doormat. But unlike many standard coir options, this one’s attractive design makes it look more than utilitarian. We found its appearance also transcended aesthetics—the weave helps trap more dirt than your standard doormat.

Made of natural fiber, this doormat does shed a little bit, as we noted in our experience, and it's written on the tag itself. However, we think the durability, style, and overall value of this rug make it worthy of the best overall pick. It also comes in two sizes, which makes it an excellent choice for nearly all-size doors.

Price at time of publish: $59-$95

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Coir}

Best Budget

L.L. Bean Everyspace Recycled Waterhog Doormat

View On L.L.Bean

The Everyspace Recycled Waterhog Doormat is a great dual indoor-outdoor mat option with a rubber backing and recycled polyester finish. While its appearance is minimal in design, you can choose between eight color options and four sizes. The polyester fiber is also naturally mildew-, shed-, and fade-resistant. It also won't crush under thick boots, like coir is susceptible to after extensive use.

The rubber backing is textured, so it's less likely to slip on less-textured surfaces, however, it may still slip on freshly waxed flooring or high-shine tiles. The raised border around the mat also helps contain rainwater—up to 1.5 gallons of water per square yard—so that the mat doesn't soak through. Be sure to allow the doormat to fully dry if exposed to excessive rain or snow. If the mat becomes caked with mud, you can rinse it with a hose and vacuum any dry debris.

Price at time of publish: $35+

_{Dimensions: Varies︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Polyester and rubber}

Best Splurge

Ruggable Coco Mata Doormat

View On Ruggable.com

The Ruggable Coco Mata Doormat is undoubtedly pricey, but we can't get over its innovative design and 100 percent washable materials. This doormat is actually two separate pieces: a doormat cover and a rubber mat. The rubber mat acts as a grippy base for the cover, which fits into a cutout in the rubber. The rubber mat also features patented ClingEffect Pucks, which keep the entire system in place. It also has holes throughout, so water can quickly drain from the cover and through the rubber. "The easiest [doormat to clean] is the Ruggable doormat because it comes in two parts—one, the base, and two, the cover," says Wayne Edelman, CEO of Meurice Garment Care. "The cover can be machine washed and hung to dry."

Not a fan of the Coco Mata design? Not a problem. Ruggable has tons of doormat cover designs to choose from Plus, once you purchase the rubber mat, you can purchase the interchangeable covers separately for a truly customizable doormat experience. As mentioned, the doormat cover is machine washable, but you do have to line dry it if your dryer doesn't have an air fluff setting. The inked designs are also UV-resistant, so they'll truly stand the test of every season's weather.

Price at time of publish: $149

_{Dimensions: 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Rubber}

Best for Rain

Calloway Mills Gatsby Rubber Door Mat

4.2

View On Amazon View On Home Depot View On Walmart

Our Ratings

• Quality
  4/5
• Durability
  5/5
• Value
  4/5
• Design
  4/5
• Effectiveness
  3.5/5

Durability is one of the first things we noted about this doormat. It earned high scores because the rubber is extremely heavy and well-made. Once you put this mat in place, it’s not going anywhere—you can rub your shoes repeatedly, and it doesn't move a single inch. This is a nice design feature for wetter climates, not only because of slippage but also because it doesn’t get water-logged the same way other types of doormats do.

It’s also mold-, mildew-, and odor-resistant. This material is great for removing excess dirt, salt, and other debris from your shoes, but it won't help you dry them because it isn't porous. It's very effective for the most part and has a nice design. The elegant fleur-de-lys pattern looks right at home just about anywhere.

Price at time of publish: $56

_{Dimensions: 48 x 30 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Rubber}

Best for Pets

Soggy Doggy Microfiber Doormat

View On Amazon

We don't want to point fingers (or paws), but our furry friends are often the (unintentional) culprits of tracking mud and dirt through our clean homes. The Soggy Doggy Doormat is specifically designed for pups who love to play in the rain and mud. This microfiber chenille towel-doormat combo can hold up to 7x its weight in water and has a great texture for ensuring your pup's paws are squeaky clean before running around your home.

The microfiber is also very soft, making it appropriate for sensitive paws and bellies compared to traditional coir or rope mats. The best part of this doormat is its machine washable and dryer-safe design, which also has a non-slip backing without the latex coating that often deteriorates over time. While this doormat is wonderful overall, we do wish it was more suitable for outdoor use (aside from enclosed porches), however, we don't fault it for this based on its otherwise stellar design.

Price at time of publish: $45-$93

_{Dimensions: 18 x 24 inches; 26 x 36 inches; 36 x 60 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Microfiber}

Best for Winter

The Rope Co. Lobster Rope Doormat

4.4

View On Food52 View On Theropeco.com

Our Ratings

• Quality
  4/5
• Durability
  5/5
• Value
  5/5
• Design
  4/5
• Effectiveness
  4/5

Though the Rope Co. Nautical Rope Doormat was one of the most expensive doormats we tested, we found that it was worth every penny, earning a perfect score in overall value. It doesn’t look too beachy and comes in nearly 30 colorways, so it suits a wide range of home styles.

But even more than its enviable style, this doormat is ultra-durable. The ropes are woven extremely tight, so it isn't susceptible to premature wear, no matter how many people wipe their feet on it each day. Another nice bonus: Because it’s made of nautical rope, the mat doesn't absorb excess water (great for rainy or snowy climates) and is mold- and mildew-resistant.

If there’s any downside, it’s that there’s no rubber on the back. Because of this, the doormat does tend to slide around a bit—a factor The Rope Co. does mention in the product listing. We found it was best to put this mat right up against the door, so you can still get the traction you need to wipe your shoes. You can also purchase a rug pad separately, if you're looking for the most traction, especially during slippery weather.

Price at time of publish: $104-$234

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 21 x 34 inches; 24 x 38 inches; 26 x 50 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Nautical rope}

Best for Sand

Crate & Barrel Teak Mat

4.9

View On Crate & Barrel

Our Ratings

• Quality
  5/5
• Durability
  5/5
• Value
  5/5
• Design
  4.5/5
• Effectiveness
  5/5

It doesn’t get much prettier than this sustainably forested teak-slatted doormat. In fact, it earned a nearly perfect score in the design category because it not only looks nice, but it’s also expertly crafted and appears much more expensive than it is. If you’re wondering where it lost out, it’s for a minor flaw—because of the slats, the doormat doesn’t dry shoes quite, as well as some other options.

Still, in wet weather, the wood dries very quickly. And overall, it's excellent at removing debris from shoes. We noticed this doormat would be perfect for beachfront and tropical locations because the dirt and debris fall between the slats rather than become trapped in fibers. To clean the sand (or other dirt and debris) away, you can simply lift up the mat and give the area a quick sweep or vacuum.

Overall, the mat is extremely heavy and durable, so it doesn’t slip and slide as you wipe your feet. Just be careful where you place this mat—we didn’t have any issues with the material staining the floor, but a few buyers experienced this.

Price at time of publish: $90

_{Dimensions: 20 x 32 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Teak}

Best Design

Letterfolk Customizable Tile Mat

4.8

View On Amazon View On Letterfolk.com View On Patternbrands.com

Our Ratings

• Quality
  5/5
• Durability
  5/5
• Value
  5/5
• Design
  5/5
• Effectiveness
  4/5

The Letterfolk Tile Mat is a real standout, not only because of the attractive black-and-white colorway (it comes in more than two dozen other colors, too!) but also because of how customizable it is. The doormat comes with additional “tiles” you can swap in and out to create your personal color pattern or even use to write a word.

This mat lacks a bit in efficacy, though—we found that although it removed debris from shoes, the glossy texture made it difficult to dry the mud and wetness adequately. In fact, the mat even became a little bit slippery in wet conditions. That said, it’s super easy to wipe down, so you can dry it in a flash.

Price at time of publish: $75-$100

_{Dimensions: 18 x 30 inches; 24 x 36 inches︱Shape: Rectangle︱Material: Flexible vinyl}