Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: OXO Good Grips SimplyTear Standing Paper Towel Holder
With a sleek design, an affordable price, and unparalleled customer praise, OXO’s SimplyTear is the best paper towel holder you can buy.
Its defining feature is a spring-activated arm that ensures an effortless, one-handed tear with every sheet. The arm is guaranteed to fit any brand or size of paper towel roll, and it can be easily adjusted for when you need to remove or replace a roll.
The SimplyTear measures 7 inches in diameter and 14 inches high. Its freestanding design lets you place it wherever you like in the kitchen, and the brushed stainless steel finish goes with any décor.
On top of that, the item comes with a weighted base and a rubber non-slip ring underneath to keep it safe and secure on the counter (even when you’re frantically grabbing at it to clean up a spill).
Runner-Up, Best Overall: simplehuman Wall-Mount Paper Towel Holder
Like many other kitchen items, one sign of a good paper towel holder is if you barely notice that you’re using it. The simplehuman Wall-Mount Paper Towel Holder is precisely that. It’s discrete, dependable, and easy to use.
With just three screws, you can mount the item to a wall, underneath a cabinet, or even inside a cabinet door—whatever best suits your home. Customers say installation is quick and stress-free.
This stainless steel holder is 13 inches long—perfect for any and all paper towel brands—and extra sturdy with a mounting bracket crafted from die-cast zinc.
One of its most beloved features is its quick-release knob, which makes changing paper towel rolls a breeze. All you have to do is squeeze the knob and it will instantly detach from the holder for easy access.
Best Design: Crate and Barrel French Kitchen Marble Paper Towel Holder
Crafted from elegant, fine-grain marble, this paper towel holder is not only convenient but a gorgeous addition to any home. It utilizes a simple freestanding design—nothing but a sturdy base and an upright spindle—to give off a modern aesthetic.
The item might not come with as many features as other paper towel holders—no high-tension arm, no rubber ring on the bottom, etc.—but it nonetheless has sparkling online reviews, with the majority of users awarding it five stars.
And the best part? This is style at a bargain. Available at Crate and Barrel, the price is right in line with your typical steel or wood paper towel holders, clocking in around $20.
Best Budget: Home Basics Paper Towel Holder
It’s not always about the frills or the glitz and glamour. Home Basics Paper Towel Holder gets the job done right and, on top of that, it comes at an unbeatable price.
Showcasing a clean, understated design, the item is available in three different colorways—black, bronze, and steel—guaranteeing the perfect look for your kitchen. And it’s freestanding, so you can easily place it wherever you like, from countertop to cupboard.
Some customers say this paper towel holder is lightweight and easy to knock over. However, users praise the product for its combination of effectiveness and affordability.
Best Splurge: Wayfair Prestige Monte Carlo Under Cabinet Paper Towel Holder
As part of Wayfair’s Prestige Monte Carlo collection, this paper towel holder comes with a touch of luxury. It’s perfect for new homeowners or those remodeling their kitchen.
The item is crafted from solid brass and available in 17 different finishes, ranging from a chic Matte Black to an ornate Antique Copper. Weighing four pounds, it will stand strong against every tug and tear. Plus, you have the option to mount it vertically or horizontally, depending on which is most convenient for the layout of your kitchen.
Top-quality does come at top dollar, however. This paper towel holder will run you at least $100, no matter which finish you choose, making it the priciest product on our list.
Best Standing: simplehuman Tension Arm Paper Towel Holder
No matter the stain, spill, or mess you’re dealing with, you will only need one free hand to tear a sheet off of this paper towel holder. The product’s adjustable, high-tension arm keeps paper towel rolls in place while you pull, ensuring a perfect tear every time. No unspooling. No wasted sheets.
The item is reasonably priced, and it comes from simplehuman, one of the most trusted names in kitchen, bath, and beauty tools. It’s crafted from stainless steel and measures in at 8 inches wide and 14 inches high, which is large enough to hold any size paper towel roll.
Customers praise this towel holder for reasons ranging from its sturdy weighted base to its portable freestanding design.
Best Wall-Mounted: Kamenstein Perfect Tear Brushed Stainless Steel Wall-Mount Paper Towel Holder
There are many benefits to wall-mounted paper towel holders, as opposed to freestanding ones. Generally, they are sturdier, better at saving space, and more aesthetically pleasing in the home. Kamenstein’s wall-mounted paper towel holder checks all these boxes and more.
With just two screws, the product can be mounted vertically or horizontally, making for a convenient and long-lasting addition to your kitchen. Its stainless steel finish will glisten wherever you decide to place it, and it’s designed to fit any size paper towel roll you buy.
Best Over-the-Cabinet: InterDesign Classico Over-the-Cabinet Paper Towel Holder
This over-the-counter paper towel holder from InterDesign offers the utmost combination of convenience and space-saving. Not only can you place your paper towels on the sturdy stainless steel bar, but you can also store numerous kitchen items in the small basket placed at the top.
Over-the-counter paper towel holders may be less common than freestanding or wall-mounted ones, but they are extremely handy because you can place them inside any cupboard door without the need for screws, tools, or handiwork. Its measurements are 12 inches long, 8 inches high, and 5.5 inches wide.
The item is just as affordable as freestanding and wall-mounted paper towel holders, and it even comes with a foam backing to protect your cupboard doors.
Best for Bathroom: Oasis Creations Touchless Wall Mount Paper Towel Dispenser
If you're looking for the perfect model for your bathroom or one that doesn't require the use of your hands, this touchless model from Oasis Creations is a great option. The exterior is made from durable plastic, and it dispenses one paper towel at a time for a more hygienic bathroom experience. It holds up to 500 paper towels, so if you're mounting this in a high traffic area, you won't have to refill it that often.