We are committed to researching, testing, and recommending the best products. We may receive commissions from purchases made after visiting links within our content. Learn more about our review process.
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Zinus Memory Foam 12-Inch Mattress at Amazon
"An ultra-plush cloud-like sleeping experience.”
"Customized support relieves pressure in your back and sides for a comfortable, restful experience.”
Best for Light Sleepers: Classic Brands Cool Gel 10.5-Inch Mattress at Amazon
“A medium-firm feel thanks to gel-infused memory foam.”
Best Innerspring: Classic Brands Innerspring 10-Inch Mattress at Amazon
“A great choice for those looking for an extra-firm mattress.”
Best Firm Mattress: Beautyrest Platinum Luxury Firm Pillow Top Ledger at Amazon
“Even if you need a firm mattress you don’t have to sacrifice a soft supportive pillow top.”
Best Soft Mattress: Signature Sleep Coil Pillow Top Mattress at Amazon
“Multiple layers of comfort foam to give you a soft surface to sleep on.”
“If you don’t want to invest in a new mattress, get the same cushy feel with a plush topper.”
01 of 07
Best Overall: Zinus Memory Foam 12 Inch Mattress
Zinus’s Memory Foam 12-inch mattress promises you an ultra-plush, cloud-like sleeping experience thanks to their engineered layers of foam and pillow top. The 1-inch microfiber quilted layer under the soft knitted jacquard cover are what initially make this mattress gentle and comfortable.
It even features natural green tea extract to ensure freshness throughout its lifetime. It is also infused with charcoal and natural plant oil to maintain cleanliness, and eliminate bacteria and odors. Click, buy, and ship; their patented compression technology allows their mattress to be conveniently rolled up and shipped to your home so you can have an easy experience setting it up.
The BioFoam under the pillow top is sure to soothe you in all of the right places. You can purchase this mattress in four standard sizes: twin, full, queen, and king. It’s also available in three styles: 8-inch, 10-inch, and 12-inch, with the 12-inch being the most popular option.
02 of 07
Best Budget: Zinus Sleep Master 10 Inch Pillow Top Spring Mattress
Luckily, finding an affordable pillow top mattress is not as hard as it may have initially seemed. The iCoil Pocketed Spring system independently transfers motion for a sound, undisturbed sleep among the hundreds of individual coils. The customized support relieves pressure in your back and sides for a comfortable, restful experience.
The pillow top on this model is made up of a 1-inch layer of Pressure Relieving Comfort Foam on top of 1.5-inches of comfort foam to make a high-density surface. You will never look at a spring coil mattress the same after this. Once thought of as one of the worst options, Zinus has made it a must-have for any home.
This model comes in twin, twin XL, full, short queen, queen, and king sizes. The thickness is customizable too and can be purchased in and 8-inch, 10-inch, 12-inch, and 13-inch style. Plus, the brand offers a 10-year limited warranty for a worry-free shopping experience at any budget.
03 of 07
Best for Light Sleepers: Classic Brands Cool Gel 10.5-Inch Mattress
This mattress offers a medium-firm feel thanks to the gel-infused memory foam which has proven to be more resilient than standard foam, to prevent tossing, turning, and absorb movement. Light sleepers, if you are sharing your bed with a partner who restlessly tosses and turns, this is the mattress for you.
The cool gel even regulates temperature, thanks to its self-ventilation system, so if you are a hot sleeper, this is also a great option for you. Pillow tops are often a concern to those sleepers who get very hot in the middle of the night. That can also lead to uneasy sleep.
It only comes in one color, a charcoal grey, so if you want a more customizable mattress, this may not be the one. However, the knit top has 4-way stretch which conforms to various body sizes. This mattress comes in six sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king.
04 of 07
Best Innerspring: Classic Brands Innerspring 10-inch Mattress
The Classic Brand’s Innerspring 10-inch model is a great choice for those looking for an extra firm mattress—even with a pillow top built-in. Chiropractors suggest firm mattresses for superior support. This model promotes proper alignment of the spine and proper weight distribution.
This innerspring mattress holds wrapped steel coils encased in individual pockets which reduces the feeling of movement throughout the entire bed, and are more durable than standard innerspring mattresses. Each innerspring moves independently to one another for a very unique feel. Most innerspring mattresses are usually priced lower than their foam counterparts, but that doesn’t mean that you are sacrificing quality.
Classic Brands also boasts a 10-year warranty to ease your mind and your pockets. This model ships easily in a compressed package like most of the other models mentioned above. You can purchase this item in standard sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king.Continue to 5 of 7 below.
05 of 07
Best Firm Mattress: Beautyrest Platinum Luxury Firm Pillow Top Ledger
Even if you need a firm mattress, you don’t have to sacrifice a soft, supportive pillow top. The Beautyrest Platinum Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress offers the best of both worlds.
Inside the Beautyrest Platinum mattress, you’ll find a combination of comfort memory foam and pocketed 15-gauge coils that will provide support for those who like a firm feel. The mattress is described as ‘medium firm,’ making it a good middle-of-the-road choice that isn’t rock hard – but also isn’t a marshmallow.
The Simmons Beautyrest mattresses have a solid reputation in the bedding industry, and this bed is no exception. It has given relief to back pain sufferers while still providing a good night of rest. And the mattress is also compatible with an adjustable bed for added versatility. For a firm pillowtop mattress, the Beautyrest Platinum Luxury Firm Pillow Top Ledger is a great option.
06 of 07
Best Soft Mattress: Signature Sleep Coil Pillow Top Mattress
If you have arthritis, persistent back problems, or are a side sleeper, you may find a soft mattress to be the only way to get a good night of sleep. The Signature Sleep Coil Pillow Top Mattress is a popular choice for a soft pillow top mattress.
Inside this coil mattress, you’ll find 13-inch independently-encased coil springs. With each coil in its own pocket, you’re less likely to be disturbed when sharing the bed with someone who tosses and turns. While the coils provide support down below, Signature Sleep includes multiple layers of comfort foam to give you a soft surface to sleep on. A cushioning comfort pad relieves worries over feeling the coils when sleeping on the bed, and four layers of support foam further soften the feel of this mattress. Lastly, a comfort foam pillow top gives that soft cloud-like sensation to this mattress.
Despite being so plush on top, people find that this mattress is still supportive for various sleeping positions. Many people find it to be more comfortable than mattresses costing several times as much. You may need to let this mattress air out upon receiving it, since a few people complained of a chemical odor. But the majority of users noticed little to no smell after unboxing the mattress. Order the Signature Sleep Coil Pillow Top Mattress for a soft, soothing night of sleep.
07 of 07
Best Topper: ExceptionalSheets Pillowtop Extra Plush Topper
If you don’t want to invest in a new pillow top mattress, get the same cushy feel with a plush topper – like this one from ExceptionalSheets.
If you want that extra-soft feel of a high-end hotel bed, the Pillowtop Extra Plush Topper is a great choice. This topper claims to be found on high-end hotels throughout the country and many satisfied sleepers find it to be a perfect at-home replacement for their favorite hotel beds.
The Pillowtop Extra Plush Topper has extra deep pockets that can accommodate mattresses up to 18 inches thick. Most people have no problem securing the pillow top topper over their existing mattress. The only real complaints come from those who try to wash their topper themselves and end up with rips or tears in the stretchy skirt that holds the topper to the bed. The manufacturer recommends only washing it in front load or high capacity washing machines. Cautious users have opted to have it professionally cleaned to avoid the potential for problems. This mattress topper will transform any mattress into a plush pillow top mattress for a fraction of the cost of a brand-new mattress – making it a wise buy for comfort seekers!