Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Alwyn Home Foam Pillowtop Mattress at Wayfair
"Customers say it’s firm enough to support their back but it's still soft."
Best Budget: Modway Quilted Pillow Top Mattress at Amazon
"A budget-friendly mattress that doesn’t skimp on comfort and quality."
Best Mattress Pad: Exceptional Sheets Fitted Mattress Pad at Amazon
"Each pad is filled with Revololoft, a fiberfill that’s similar to goose down."
Best King: Sweetnight King Mattress in a Box at Amazon
"Customers cite head-to-toe comfort and price as selling points."
Best Queen: Signature Sleep Queen Mattress at Amazon
"Provides optimal support and lasting comfort."
"An ideal pick if you prefer your mattress to be on the firm side."
Best for Side Sleepers: Zinus Memory Foam Mattress at Amazon
"Provides exceptional support for your spine and midsection."
Best Overall: Alwyn Home 11" Plush Premium Foam Pillowtop Mattress
If you've decided that a pillow top mattress is for you, you can't go wrong with the Alwyn Home 11" Plush Premium Foam Pillowtop Mattress. This luxurious mattress is crafted from CertiPUR-US foam, which means that it's free of harmful chemicals and toxins. It's available in eight different sizes from twin to California King, so you can find the right size for your space. Another huge benefit? It's hypoallergenic so it's resistant to mold, dust, and other allergens that might trigger those with asthma or allergies.
This foam mattress is billed as low-motion transfer, which is great for partners that have different sleep schedules. Thousands of happy customers agree that this pillow top mattress lives up to the claims and is firm enough to support their back (and other areas that need extra support), but it's still soft and plush. Other customers noted that this feels way more expensive than it actually is, and they would easily buy it again as opposed to a more expensive brand. If you want to feel like you’re floating on a cloud as you drift off to sleep, this Alwyn Home mattress will definitely do the trick.
Note that it takes about 72 hours for this mattress to expand and reach its full size.
Best Budget: Modway Ultimate Quilted Pillow Top Mattress
For a budget-friendly mattress that doesn’t skimp on comfort and quality, the Jenna Innerspring Mattress from Modway will help you enjoy a peaceful night’s sleep—at half the cost of other bedding of its caliber. Built to be responsive to the needs of stomach, side, and back sleepers, the Jenna helps reduce pressure on your back, shoulders, and neck, while also firmly contouring to your body. Thanks to the quilted polyester tight-top surface and individually wrapped pocket coils, any motion or bouncing is absorbed, which is particularly great for partners with different sleep habits or schedules.
Reviews are effusive for this mattress, which comes with 8.5-inch individually wrapped coils, a 1-inch responsive foam, foam padding, and a padded polyester tight-top. Consumers have reported that the Jenna is perfect for anyone suffering from hip or back pain and that it’s an excellent pick for the price point.
Best Mattress Pad: ExceptionalSheets Extra Plush Fitted Mattress Pad
On the hunt for a mattress topper that offers an excellent amount of cushioning? The ExceptionalSheets Extra Plush Fitted Mattress Topper is near-unparalleled in its ability to relieve your nightly aches and pains and give you a good night’s sleep. This topper is crafted from unique polyester fiber clusters and a polyester-cotton blend—each pad is filled with Revololoft, a fiberfill that’s similar to goose and duck down, without the feathers—which results in a soft, breathable feel. It’s also hypoallergenic and very effective at protecting against allergens and bacteria.
There are thousands of rave reviews for the ExceptionalSheets Extra Plush Fitted Mattress Topper, with one citing that it feels like a “warm embrace," and another saying that their bed “looks and feels like a hotel bed."
Best King: Sweetnight King Mattress in a Box
If you're shopping for a pillow top king mattress online, the 12" Sweetnight King Mattress is a top-rated option that will help you sleep better at night. This mattress is constructed of individually wrapped innerspring coils for firm support and topped with gel memory foam for pressure relief and comfort. Memory foam is known to be one of the best materials for relieving pressure points and cradling your body, so if you suffer from back pain or hip pain, this will be a good option for you. The quilted pillow top cover adds a plush element to this medium firm mattress and it's hypoallergenic, which is perfect for allergy sufferers.
Available in four different sizes that are reasonably priced, you can't go wrong with this mattress in a box. Customers consistently call this mattress "the most amazing king-sized mattress," citing the head-to-toe comfort and price as the biggest selling points. This mattress comes compressed in a box for easy delivery so it takes about 72 hours for it to expand.
Best Queen: Signature Sleep Queen Mattress
Crafted from high-quality rayon that absorbs moisture (no more sweaty tossing and turning!) and high-density foam that allows the mattress to mold to your body’s natural shape, the Signature Sleep Queen Mattress provides optimal support and lasting comfort. The support in this mattress comes from the 10-inch independently-encased coils that help distribute weight evenly, eliminate motion transfer, and minimize pressure on the body. On top of the coils, there's a memory foam pillow top for added softness. The eco-friendly foam material is CertiPUR-US certified, so it’s made without harmful chemicals like mercury and lead.
The vast majority of consumers have given the Signature Sleep Queen Mattress five stars, with many stating that it’s helped relieve back pain. Though it may feel firm right out of the box, it does a great job of eventually conforming to your body and enveloping you in softness.
Best Firm: Simmons Beautyrest Silver 12" Firm Pillow Top Mattress
The Simmons Beautyrest Silver 12" Firm Pillow Top Mattress is an ideal pick if you prefer your mattress to be on the firm side. The sophisticated design features pocketed coils, which are individually wrapped coils that mimic the kind of support that you would get from a memory foam mattress. Because the coils are individually wrapped, movement on one side of the bed will stay confined to that area. This makes it possible to get up during the night or early in the morning without disturbing your partner.
There are 490 extra coils in the center of the mattress to enhance contouring back support, and cooling technology promotes airflow during the night. Again, there's a high level of support with this mattress, but if you prefer enhanced support coupled with a supremely soft top layer, this may not be the right option for you. Customers describe this mattress as firm or medium-firm, with one reviewer writing that it was a tad too hard for them. As with most other mattresses on this list, the pillow top is hypoallergenic and there are multiple sizes to choose from.
Best for Side Sleepers: Zinus Memory Foam Cloud-like Mattress
For side sleepers, the Zinus Memory Foam 12-inch Cloud-like Mattress provides exceptional support for your spine and midsection. It’s comprised of two inches of microfiber and foam-quilted jacquard, plus two inches of memory foam, three inches of comfort foam, and five inches of high-density base support foam. Another major perk is that the memory foam is infused with charcoal, green tea, and natural plant oil, so you don’t have to worry about pesky odors, which can be an issue with other memory foam mattresses.
Reviewers like that the Zinus Memory Foam Cloud-like Mattress is perfectly firm and fluffy. Several customers also pointed out that if you have questions or concerns about your mattress, the customer service at Zinus is extremely friendly and helpful.
Composition In addition to the pillowtop, you need to consider what the mattress underneath is made from. Today, most mattresses are made with innersprings, foam, or a combination of both. Foam mattresses contour to your body more readily but make it harder to shift around. On the other hand, innerspring mattresses are more firm and bouncy, which means it’s easier to disturb your partner.
Support Pillow top mattresses are inherently soft, but you can still choose different levels of support and firmness. Firm mattresses are often preferred by those with back pain and stomach sleepers, while medium and soft mattresses are better for back and side sleepers.
Trial period If you’re buying a mattress online, there’s no way to know if you like it until it arrives. That’s why it’s important to see if the retailer offers a trial period so you can test the mattress out at home. Consider things like the trial length, refund policy, and shipping logistics.