The 5 Absolute Best Pillows for Combination Sleepers of 2022

Best Overall: Snuggle-Pedic Adjustable Memory Foam Pillows

5

View On Amazon

If you're a combination sleeper looking for a pillow that will keep you slumbering soundly all night long, we recommend our top pick, the Snuggle-Pedic Original Memory Foam Pillow, because of its breathable cover and adjustable interior foam fill. The pillow's perforated cover ensures that you won't wake up to an uncomfortably warm pillow in the middle of the night. Our tester said this pillow maintained its coolness for the entire time she laid on it in The Lab and said she felt significant support in her neck, which is typically a problem area during sleep.

Our tester said this pillow immediately screamed luxury to her after examining it and finding no stray threads, stitching or filling. She loved it's cool-to-the-touch design and how it perfectly filled out the queen pillow case used for testing. Although our tester said she felt this pillow was slightly on the expensive end of a price spectrum, she said its cooling factor and high-quality design certainly made it worth spending more.

We also sent this pillow home with a volunteer tester, who slept on it for one month and evaluated its long-term durability. She said she felt support from this pillow no matter her position—on her side or stomach—and the foam core allowed for comfortable airflow throughout the night. She did notice that this pillow loses loft over time, so she recommends fluffing it after each use. She added the additional fill after several weeks to maintain her desired loft.

Best Cooling: Coop Home Goods Eden Adjustable Pillow

4.9

View On Amazon View On Walmart View On Coophomegoods.com

For combination sleepers battling warm temperatures, night sweats, or hot flashes, Coop Home Goods' Eden Pillow covers it all. This pillow is filled with shredded gel memory foam and microfiber, allowing better dispersement of heat as you sleep. If you're a pillow-flipper and restless sleeper, you'll be happy to know our tester didn't flip this pillow during testing and said it stays cool all night long without becoming stuffy and hot. The gusseted sides of this pillow also keep the filling in place and prevent the dreaded "pillow pinch."

Unlike other adjustable pillows, the Coop Eden pillow offers an inner, zipped lining that keeps the stuffing together while you wash the cover. A zipper on the side of the pillow cover also allows you to adjust the fill according to your sleeping needs. Our tester said this pillow fluffed right back to its original size after being washed, which she appreciated as a stomach sleeper, who likes to adjust her pillows to a less firm fill.

You can also request more filling from the company if the pillow is too soft—you may find it only needs a simple adjustment to create the perfect pillow for any sleeping position. Note, it may take a few nights of sleeping on the pillow to find what works best. Overall, our tester said she loves this pillow's customization and fully machine-washable design make it truly stand out against other pillows.

Best Adjustable: Snuggle-Pedic Ultra-Luxury Bamboo Shredded Memory Foam Pillow

4

View On Amazon

If you're a combination sleeper looking for a pillow that will keep you slumbering soundly all night long, the Snuggle-Pedic Ultra Luxury Pillow is a perfect choice because of the adjustability of the foam. Whether you are a side, stomach, or back sleeper, you can add or reduce the quantity of shredded memory foam to meet your support needs. Unlike some other "adjustable" pillows, Snuggle-Pedic includes a convenient zipper on the edge to make adding or subtracting foam a breeze. The memory foam is also hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant—a major plus for anyone with allergies.

Another plus? If you're not happy with the support, you can send the pillow back for a free, custom adjustment from Snuggle-Pedic. While this service involves an extra step, it's complimentary. With adjustable support and free customization from the manufacturer, this pillow will accommodate just about any combination sleeper.

Best Organic: Avocado Green Pillow

4.5

View On Avocadogreenmattress.com

The Avocado Green Pillow is the ideal all around certified organic pillow for anyone looking to prioritize their environmental impact, while still enjoying a luxurious sleep experience every night. Our tester said this pillow had a very soft exterior cover and the filling was incredibly solid. It did not immediately spring back up after pushing it gently with her hand. While testing this pillow in our lab, our tester was shocked that this pillow never changed temperature and felt soft, yet supportive at the same time.

Aside from this pillow's incredibly comfortable feel and design, it has an impressive list of certifications on almost every material used in its design. The interior ribbon filling is made of GOLS-certified organic latex rubber foam, the same latex used in Avocado's mattresses, and GOTS-certified organic kopak tree fiber. This filling is encased in an organic cotton jersey liner and then covered with the GOTS-certified organic cotton quilted cover. Our tester noted that the filling did easily catch in the liner zipper when she tried adding and removing fill. While this is not a major issue, it's still a design issue to keep in mind. The cover had minimal shrinkage after we washed it in the lab and our tester said it was still easy to zip shut, once she had squeezed the liner back into the cover.

We also sent this pillow home with a long-term tester, who used it for one month. She said that this pillow was clearly high-quality and loved its non-toxic materials, but said that it was a bit too firm for her liking, even with the adjustable fill. She also said that she could feel the texture of the filling, even with two layers of lining and cover, plus a pillow case, over it. We recommend looking for a different pick if texture and a lower fill are at the top of your pillow priorities. Overall, both of our testers said they did enjoy using this pillow, and appreciated its eco-conscious design.