The 9 Best Pool Toy Storage Organizers of 2023

Best Overall

Keter Brushwood 120 Gallon Resin Large Deck Box

View On Amazon

The Keter Brightwood 120-Gallon Resin Deck Box is one of the best models available when it comes to both pool toy storage and deck boxes. The best deck boxes are versatile and water and weather-proof. They stand up to the elements, while protecting everything from gardening tools and grilling supplies, to kids’ toys and pool supplies. This pick does all of that, plus looks stylish enough to be on full display in your backyard or on your deck. 

The resin deck box has an attractive, neutral, faux wood finish that’s UV and water-resistant. It also has a roomy interior with a 120-gallon capacity, for some of the larger items you’ll want to stash, including bulky floats and basketball hoops. (It does not, however, have any dedicated compartments.) There’s no worry about fingers getting caught in the lid. As you’d expect in a high-quality storage container, this one has a soft-close mechanism to protect you. When it is closed, you can add a lock (sold separately) for security. 

Plus, the deck box doubles as a bench, thanks to an impressive 800-pound seating capacity. It is truly a versatile, functional, and spacious pick that does more than just storing pool toys. We feel, for that reason, that it would be a great addition to any household.

Price at time of publish: $200

_{Dimensions: 54.5 x 23.5 x 21.7 inches | Material: Resin | Storage Capacity: 120 gallons}

Best Budget

Suncast 73 Gallon Water Resistant Deck Box with Wheels

View On Wayfair

Deck boxes—one of the most common forms of pool toy storage—are surprisingly expensive to add to your backyard. This one by Suncast is proof that you don’t have to spend a ton of money on a quality item, though. Sure, you will sacrifice a bit on overall storage space—this one has a smaller 73-gallon capacity—but, you actually gain some features that add to overall functionality. 

This water, rust, and UV-resistant resin box is perfect for anyone who wants to be able to move their storage bin around their yard and trust that it can withstand the elements, including water coming from their pool toys. It has wheels and a pull handle, so you can more readily move the whole thing—even when it’s at full capacity. This is especially handy for off-season storage and moving it into your garage or a shed. (Since it doesn’t lock, you’ll likely want to wheel it into one of these spaces for the winter.)

And although it’s rather utilitarian in appearance, you will appreciate the 300-pound top weight capacity that allows you to use the organizer as a bench. One or two people can perch while kids swim nearby.

Price at time of publish: $129

_{Dimensions: 25.5 x 46 x 23.75 inches | Material: Resin | Storage Capacity: 73 gallons}

Best Deck Box

East Oak 100-Gallon Large Deck Box

View On Amazon

If you want a solid option for storing pool toys on your deck, don’t sleep on this 100-gallon box from East Oak. Though attractive enough to put on display in your eating and lounging area, it’s made of strong resin that's waterproof, weather-proof, and UV-resistant. That means, thanks to its durable material, the box won't fade, crack, peel, or age prematurely, no matter how severe the weather gets in your area. 

It’s not divided into compartments, but the large capacity means you’ll have room to toss all kinds of things inside—even larger items like boogie boards. When you’re reaching inside, you don’t have to worry about the whole thing slamming down, either. It has soft-opening and closing hinges. It even comes with a padlock, so you can put everything under lock and key overnight. And the icing on the cake? It also has an impressive 660-pound weight capacity, so you can use the box as an outdoor bench when you need more seating during a pool party.

Just note: assembly can be tricky, but once you have everything set up, you’re bound to be satisfied with the fairly realistic wicker design.

Price at time of publish: $180

_{Dimensions: 48 x 21.5 x 25.7 inches | Material: Resin | Storage Capacity: 100 gallons}

Best Heavy-Duty

Lifetime 60186 Heavy-Duty Outdoor Storage Deck Box

View On Amazon

It may not look like all that much, but this pool storage organizer presents one of the best overall values. It’s made from a heavy-duty, high-density polyethylene material that won't fade, crack, or warp, even if you live in an area prone to extreme weather. It’s the perfect option for stashing all of your pool toys once you’ve closed your swimming area for the season. Not to mention, you’re able to add a lock for security—a feature lacking in other picks on our list.

Just note: if you plan to move the box to another spot, like the garage, for the off-season, you may want to move it before filling it up. Molded handles do make it easier to lift and move the box when needed, but it can get very heavy when packed to its 116-gallon capacity—plus, it doesn’t have any wheels. 

When in use, you’ll appreciate the spring-hinged lid, since it won't slam shut on your fingers. Plus, the lid has a 250-pound weight capacity, so you can use it as a bench as well. If there’s any downside, it’s that this particular box is more difficult to assemble than some of our other choices.

Price at time of publish: $170

_{Dimensions: 50.3 x 23.2 x 26 inches | Material: High-density polyethylene (HDPE) | Storage Capacity: 116 gallons}

Best with Wheels

Keter Capri Outdoor Plastic Storage Box

View On Amazon

Because pool toy storage organizers tend to be heavy-duty to withstand the elements, and need to be large enough to store a lot of bulky items, they tend to be rather stationary. But, if you want something a little more mobile—especially convenient if you have a smaller backyard and need to rearrange things from time to time—the Keter Capri is a worthy option. Though smaller than most of the others on the list, the 80-gallon toy storage organizer has two small wheels at one end, plus a handle to help you pull it where you need it.

And although it has an attractive basketweave design, the box is actually weather-resistant and won't fade, warp, crack, or peel in wet or exceptionally warm weather. (It’s probably not the best choice for off-season storage, though, since it’s not entirely waterproof.) Adding to the pool toy organizer’s functionality, the lid has a high 550-pound capacity, so a couple people can use it as a bench while they supervise any swimmers or socialize poolside. There's also a spot for a lock.

Price at time of publish: $131

_{Dimensions: 48.43 x 21.06 x 22.44 inches | Material: Plastic, rattan | Storage Capacity: 80 gallons}

Best with Noodler Holder

Pottery Barn Teak Outdoor Pool Float Storage

View On Pottery Barn

It should come as no surprise that Pottery Barn makes one of the most stylish options for your poolside. The pool toy storage organizer is crafted out of solid teak wood to match the rest of your outdoor furniture and make your space look like a five-star resort. 

The biggest drawback is that this option doesn’t have an enclosed storage area, which renders it unsuitable for off-season storage and won’t protect your toys in bad weather. If you just want a solid daily option that looks great, though, this is it. Not to mention, the open-air design will keep your belongings ventilated in between uses.

The storage piece has two dedicated compartments: one larger open area for big items such as noodles and boogie boards, and another large basket to corral smaller items like children’s inner tubes, rings, and other little pool toys. Again, it’s all ventilated, plus the teak dries out quickly, so your toys will receive plenty of airflow—read: great for preventing mold growth. 

Price at time of publish: $399

_{Dimensions: 36 x 20.75 x 23 inches | Material: Teak | Storage Capacity: 88 pounds}

Best Mesh

Improvements Modern Blue Pool Storage Bin

View On Amazon

If you’re worried about mold growth, and don’t necessarily need an enclosed option to protect your toys from weather, a simple mesh cart is a decent choice for storing your pool toys. While it’s not the most attractive out there, this pick dries very quickly and has plenty of ventilation to promote airflow. It also has a number of different compartments, including a larger basket, and multiple smaller pockets for loose items like rings. 

The entire cart is highly portable, too, since it’s nice and lightweight. The nylon basket sits atop wheels, so you can push it around your pool deck. Go slowly, though, as this isn’t the sturdiest option out there, so it may tip if you go too quickly over any seams in your patio pavers. Overall, though, it’s a budget-friendly pick that’ll get the job done.

Price at time of publish: $60

_{Dimensions: 34.75 x 8.3 x 4.4 inches | Material: Nylon | Storage Capacity: Not listed}

Best Small

Suncast 22 Gallon Water Resistant Storage Bench

View On Amazon View On Wayfair View On Walmart

If your pool takes up the better part of your backyard or you only have a few small items to store, you can get away with a much smaller storage solution like this 22-gallon resin box from Suncast. The box is relatively attractive, thanks to a design that’s styled to resemble planked wood, plus is roomy enough to contain items like balls and a ring toss game or two. 

It’s not fully waterproof, but it is weather-resistant, so it won’t fade, crack, or warp with extended outdoor use—especially if you follow manufacturer recommendations and clean it annually with a mixture of soap and water. The box is functional beyond storage, too. It has a hinged top that easily opens and closes, and the lid can support up to 150 pounds for use as a seat. Just be sure to keep this box filled at less than 10 pounds. It may tip otherwise. 

Price at time of publish: $54

_{Dimensions: 22 x 20.5 x 17 inches | Material: Resin | Storage Capacity: 22 gallons}