The 8 Best Toaster Ovens to Buy in 2017

Shop for the best toaster ovens available from brands like Breville and Oster

Toaster ovens have grown up, in more ways than one. They’re not just a horizontal way to toast bread or heat a slice of pizza. You can find toaster ovens large enough to toast six or more slices of bread at a time. Some have two racks for holding even more food.

But that’s not all. Toaster ovens are being made with features that rival standard ovens. Some are large enough and versatile enough to replace your traditional oven for many tasks. Many can cook a 12-inch pizza or bake a 9- by 13-inch...MORE cake. Others have features that your oven might not have, like a removable tray for cleaning, or a rotisserie function.

A toaster oven can create extra cooking space for large families, or it can be a convenient appliance for singles. Or it can be the only oven in a cabin, vacation home, RV, or small apartment. Even if you never make toast.

  • 01 of 08
    Breville Smart Oven Pro Convection Toaster Oven with Element IQ
    Courtesy of

    This oven may be smarter than your current oven, with 10 preset functions and an auto-shutoff feature. There are independent heating elements that the oven automatically adjusts for precise cooking. Meanwhile, the oven suggests the time and temperature for the presets, and remembers your selections so you can cook the same thing the same way the next time.

    It has temperature conversion and frozen food functions, and can keep food warm for up to two hours, just in case someone’s late coming home...MORE for dinner. The slow-cook function is ideal for foods that need a long, slow cooking time, and it has a convection fan for even, speedy cooking.

    The oven comes with a 12-inch-square baking pan, a 12-inch-square broiling rack, and a 13-inch nonstick pizza pan. If you’re using your own cookware, this will handle most 3 1/2-quart Dutch ovens with their lids, or a 5-quart Dutch oven with foil in place of the lid.

    One small feature that makes a difference for many users is the replaceable internal halogen light, so cooks can check the cooking process without opening the door and taking the food out to get a good look.

  • 02 of 08
    Oster Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven
    Courtesy of

    This oven will toast six slices of bread or cook a 12-inch frozen pizza, whole chicken, or a 9- x 13-inch pan of brownies. There is only one rack, but there are two rack positions, so you can fit taller foods or pans.

    Preset cooking functions include bake, convection bake, broil, toast, pizza, defrost, and warm, and the functions offer a suggested time and temperature, but you can adjust both the time and temperature for your recipe. You can set the toast function for light through dark toasting.

    T...MOREhere’s an internal light so you can check the progress of the food as it cooks.

    While this is rated to hold a 9x13-inch pan, it has to be one without handles. A straight-sided metal baking pan will fit no problem; your 9- by 13-inch Pyrex dish will be too long.

  • 03 of 08
    Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven
    Courtesy of

    If you need a toaster oven that’s small, less complicated, and budget-friendly, this one is for you. It can handle up to four slices of toast or a 9-inch pizza. There’s only one rack, but there are two rack positions.

    The setting are simple, with options for bake, broil, and toast. It also has a 30-minute timer that shuts the oven off automatically, or you can use the stay-on setting for foods that need a longer cooking time.

    The door design on this toaster oven is unique—it lifts up and out of...MORE the way, offering easier access to the top of the food without taking it out of the oven. When it’s time to take food out of the oven, you can set a dish on the counter right in front of the oven, since the door won’t be in the way.

    The downside of the door design is that you’ll lose a lot of heat when the oven is wide open. This oven also comes with a baking pan.

  • 04 of 08
    BLACK+DECKER TO1313SBD 4-Slice Toaster Oven
    Courtesy of

     If you’re looking for a compact, budget-friendly toaster oven that can toast your bread and heat your pizza, but you don’t need an oven-replacement, this one fits the bill. It can toast up to four slices of bread at a time and it has space for a 9-inch pizza.

    This has functions for baking, broiling, toasting, and keeping food warm. For toasting, it has different toast settings so you’ll get just the right level of brownness, and the 30-minute timer lets you cook foods longer. The removable crumb...MORE tray makes it easy to clean.

    This comes with a baking pan, broiling rack, and toasting rack.

    Continue to 5 of 8 below.
  • 05 of 08
    KitchenAid 12
    Courtesy of

    This appliance is a full-featured oven that can also toast your bread or bagels. It has nine preset functions: bake, pizza, asado roast, toast, broil, cookie, bagel, keep warm, and reheat.

    The asado roast function is unique. It starts with convection to brown and crisp the exterior of a roast, then the fan turns off and the food continues to cook more slowly, so the interior is cooked perfectly.

    There’s a 120-minute timer to remind you when your food is done and the oven’s interior has a nonstick...MORE finish for easy cleaning.

    This oven has two racks, so you can cook two 12-inch pizzas at once, or you can cook with a single rack in the upper or lower position. It includes a 12-inch square non-stick multipurpose pan, a 12-inch-square broiling rack, a cooling rack, and non-stick drip tray.

  • 06 of 08
    Black and Decker Stainless Steel Countertop Convection Oven
    Courtesy of

    Like other ovens, this one features a variety of presets including cookies, pizza, frozen snacks, potato. The functions include bake, broil, toast, and bagel, and the convection fan can be turned on or off. There’s a large digital display that shows time and temperature, but it’s not backlit, so sometimes it can be hard to read.

    The oven can fit a 12-inch pizza thanks to a rounded bump-out on the back of the oven and there are two positions for the rack. The 120-minute timer shuts the oven off...MORE automatically and announces itself with a single bell to let you know the time is up.

    The crumb tray removes easily from the outside for easy cleaning, and to keep crumbs from getting stuck in the door. The oven should be placed so the door can rest on the counter when it’s open, or the spring that holds it can become overstretched over time.

    A baking pan is included.

  • 07 of 08
    Hamilton Beach Toastation Toaster Oven
    Courtesy of

    When space is at a premium, this toaster and oven combo could be just what you’re looking for. It combines a traditional pop-up toaster with a small, countertop oven.

    The settings are simple. There’s a slider to choose either the toaster or oven, and dials to control oven temperature and toast settings. A cancel button halts the cooking process.

    The wide top slot can hold bagels or thick toast, and the oven can hold two open-faced sandwiches.

  • 08 of 08
    Hamilton Beach Countertop Oven with Convection and Rotisserie
    Courtesy of

    This toaster oven has one very large advantage over others—it has a rotisserie than can handle up to a five-pound chicken. It has two racks, so it can hold two 12-inch pizzas or two 9- by 13-inch casseroles at the same time.

    The controls are simple. One knob controls the temperature, the second controls the function (bake, rotisserie, convection, or broil) and the last knob is the timer, for cooking up to 120 minutes, or you can set it to stay on.

    There is no keep-warm function. While there’s no...MORE dedicated toast setting, the broiler setting is used for toasting. It includes two baking pans, a broiler rack, and rotisserie accessories.