Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
When it comes time to replace your toilet seat, you may think that it’s as simple as finding one that fits. But there are actually a lot of styles and features available that can make your porcelain throne more comfortable and easier to use and clean. It does need to fit, of course, with the shape matching that of your toilet. You can also consider what kind of material you want your toilet seat to be made of, with plastic and wood being the two most widely available choices. Finally, consider extra features like a soft-close hinge that will make your toilet seat easier to use and last longer.
Here are the best toilet seats that are easy to install and comfortable to use.
Best Overall: American Standard Mainstream Elongated Slow Close Toilet Seat
Stain, bacteria, and mold resistant material
Shape: Elongated | Material: Plastic | Dimensions: 14.87 x 2.87 x 19.12 inches | Weight: Not listed
Longtime reputable bathroom hardware manufacturer American Standard is a popular choice for both toilets and toilet seats for their history of quality products. The Mainstream Elongated Slow Close toilet seat works with most toilets and is made of a plastic material that is resistant to stains, bacteria, and mold, which can help with keeping it clean. It also has a slow-close hinge that will prevent loud slams or pinched fingers. At less than $30, it’s still budget-friendly even with the top-of-the-line features. The hinges themselves can become loose over time, which can result in some seat wiggling.
Best Budget: Kohler Brevia Quick-Release Elongated Toilet Seat
Numerous colors available
No soft close
Shape: Elongated | Material: Plastic | Dimensions: 0.75 x 14.19 x 18.63 inches | Weight: 4.6 pounds
For a budget-friendly pick that will still hold up well, the Brevia Quick-Release Elongated Toilet Seat from Kohler is a good pick. It is a fairly basic model, without some of the extra features that are commonly found in more expensive toilet seats. But it does use a quick-release hinge system to attach and comes in seven different colors. If you want to find a quality seat without breaking the bank, this model from Kohler is just what you need.
Best Elongated: BEMIS Jamestown Model #1530SLOW 000
Shape: Elongated | Material: Enameled wood | Dimensions: 18.81 x 14.37 x 2 inches | Weight: 7.87 pounds
Elongated toilet seats tend to be more popular than their smaller, round counterparts when homeowners have the space. The Jamestown Model #1530SLOW 000 from BEMIS sets itself apart from others by being adjustable from front to back, including a quiet close hinge, and having an STA-TITE fastening system to make wiggling almost nonexistent. It’s definitely not the cheapest toilet seat available but is still a good value for the price.
Best Round: Kohler Figure ReadyLatch Quiet-Close Round-Front Toilet Seat
Grip-Tight hardware and bumpers
Shape: Round | Material: Plastic | Dimensions: 16.62 x 14.81 x 1.12 inches | Weight: Not listed
The Kohler Figure ReadyLatch Quiet-Close Round-Front Toilet Seat has everything that you need in a toilet seat. Round seats tend to be popular in half baths, smaller bathrooms, and older homes. This toilet seat uses Grip-Tight hardware for installation and Grip-Tight bumpers to keep the seat from sliding while in use. It also has a quiet close to make closing the lid easy and seamless. It is quite expensive at almost $50 but will hold up well over time and a lot of use.
Best Open Front: BEMIS Round Plastic Toilet Seat White
Available in round and elongated
Not whisper close
Shape: Round or Elongated | Material: Plastic | Dimensions: 15.19 x 14.31 x 1.63 inches | Weight: 3.3 pounds
Open Front toilet seats offer less area for potential messes, which is why they are commonly seen in public and shared restrooms. The Round Plastic Toilet Seat White from BEMIS offers great value and easy cleaning. It comes in both round and elongated shapes, so every homeowner can find one that will work for their toilet. The hardware is all non-corroding, so it won’t need to be replaced anytime soon. However, the toilet seat does not come with any special features and definitely looks more industrial than some other models.
Best Bidet Toilet Seat: Bio Bidet Electric Bidet Seat for Elongated Toilets in White with Fusion Heating Technology
Requires complex installation
Shape: Elongated | Material: Plastic with stainless steel nozzle | Dimensions: 20.8 x 18.5 x 6.8 inches | Weight: 10.4 pounds
For the ultimate toilet experience, consider the BioBidet Electric Bidet seat. The seat itself is heated, as is the water that comes from the bidet nozzle. It also has a nightlight so that even midnight trips to the bathroom go smoothly. It does require all of these extra features to be hooked up to water and power, so be ready for some more complicated installation. As expected, the price tag for this seat is also on the higher end at around $250.
Best Heated: Brondell LumaWarm Heated Nightlight Toilet Seat
Three temperature settings
Shape: Round | Material: Plastic | Dimensions: 18.5 x 14 x 3 inches | Weight: 4.6 pounds
If you want a luxury touch without spending all of your budget on a toilet seat, the Brondell LumaWarm Heated Nightlight Toilet Seat provides one of the most important luxurious features: a heated seat. At just over $100, it is a splurge but not one that will completely break the bank. It has three temperature settings and a blue nightlight for use in the dark. This seat also features a slow-close lid, which is a nice extra detail. It does require a connection to a GFCI outlet, which may not be close to your commode.
Best Wood Toilet Seat: BEMIS Natural Reflections Model #59401NI 568
Made of solid bamboo
Metal hinges visible
Shape: Round | Material: Wood | Dimensions: 16.85 x 14.25 x 2.2 inches | Weight: Not listed
If you’re looking for a toilet seat to complement your natural decor, the BEMIS Natural Reflections Model #59401NI 568 in Dark Bamboo looks and performs great. It is made of solid bamboo, which resists warping or cracking common in humid places like the bathroom. The hinge hardware is brushed nickel, which can be jarring because it is so visible in the overall design. This is still a great seat at a decent price, even with the visible hinges.
Our top pick is the American Standard Mainstream Elongated Slow Close Toilet Seat (view at Lowe’s). It is a good value, has all of the top features like a slow-close hinge and an easy-to-clean surface. Close seconds are the BEMIS Jamestown Model #1530SLOW 000 (view at Home Depot) for those looking for an elongated seat and the Kohler Figure ReadyLatch Quiet-Close Round-Front Toilet Seat (view at Lowe’s) for a round seat. Both have specialty fasteners that keep the seat in place during use.
What to Look for in a Toilet Seat
When purchasing a toilet seat, the most important consideration is the shape of your toilet. There are two common shapes: round and elongated. Round toilets are often found in older homes, while elongated toilets are more popular with modern plumbing fixtures. It’s important to know the shape of your toilet so you can pick a seat that fits.
Toilet seats are typically made of either plastic or wood, and there are pros and cons to each material. Plastic seats tend to be lighter and have a longer lifespan, while wooden seats are sturdy and heavier. Many people also think wooden toilet seats add a touch of luxury to the bathroom.
Does it drive you crazy when you close the toilet seat, and it makes a loud noise? If so, you may want to consider a soft-close toilet seat, which is designed to shut slowly and quietly.
Why Trust The Spruce?
This article was researched and written by Katie Begley, a freelance writer specializing in home and family products. Katie has been writing for The Spruce since 2019. To create this list, she looked for toilet seats that performed well, had top features like soft-close hinges, and fit a variety of budgets.