One of your closest friends hands you a beautifully wrapped gift, and you get excited ... until you open it and discover that it's one of the ugliest sweaters you've ever seen. What do you say? Or should you say anything?
Or you go to your friends' annual gift exchange, eagerly anticipating unwrapping the set of crystal wine glasses you've been hinting about for the past several months, only to be disappointed by seeing a set of steak knives ... and you're vegan. Should you remind your friend that you don't have a need for the knives? Or is it better to sit there, smile, and pretend you're happy?
It's an awkward situation at best. But it's up to you to turn things around and remember that this isn't a reflection of anything other than the fact that someone made an error in judgment.
We've all been there. And it's not always easy to do the right thing. You definitely don't want to hurt the feelings of someone who thought enough of you to give you the gift. And you want to avoid having an awkward moment when you feel as though you have to say something, but you're not sure what to say.
Being surprised by a bad gift can be extremely disheartening. But remember that a gift exchange is more about being with friends and enjoying the time together than about the gift itself. After someone gives you a gift, you should always thank the person, even if the item is something you don't want, need, or like. It's not easy, but it shows good manners.
It also shows respect for your relationship with others. After all, you don't want this one incident to create a wedge between you and the giver.
What to Do
You might be tempted to regift the item, which is fine, but before you decide to do that, think about whether or not the giver will expect to see it when he or she goes to your home. If that's the case, keep it and pull it out right before the visit. After a year or two, you can put the item away for good or donate it to a worthwhile charity.
If the gift is a wearable item, wear it once when you will see the person and then put it away for donation later. It's always a good idea to keep it for a year, though, because the gift giver might ask about it, and you don't want to have to lie.
What Not to Do
Never be rude and say or do something that would hurt someone's feelings or embarrass her. You don't want to have to backpedal and spend the rest of the time apologizing for something you said. After you thank the friend for her thoughtfulness, change the subject and hope that she doesn't ask what you like most about the item.
Writing a Thank You Note
No matter what gift you receive, you should always write a thank you note to the person who thought enough of you to give you the gift. When writing the thank you note, mention the gift at least once, but put emphasis on some other aspect of the occasion. That at least acknowledges that you appreciate the thought behind the gift, but more importantly, it shows that you value the relationship with the person.
Here are some examples of thank you notes for that unwanted item:
I'm so happy you were able to join us in our anniversary celebration. Thank you for the [named gift], but even more important, thank you for coming. I can't wait to get the photos uploaded so we can relive those special moments.
Looking forward to seeing you soon,
Thank you for the beautiful birthday card and [named gift]. Can you believe we're the same age as our parents were when we first met? Although it's a sobering reminder of how quickly time passes, it just goes to show how strong our friendship is.
Thank you for the holiday sweater. Every time I wear it, I will think of you. I've always enjoyed our annual holiday lunch and gift exchange. Maybe we can get together more often throughout the year.
Thank you for the coasters you brought back from Greece. It was so nice of you to think about us during your trip. Let's get together soon so you can tell me all about it.
Being Poised and Gracious
If you are poised and gracious when you receive a bad gift, you avoid making the other person feel bad during a time of celebration. It's about being kind to someone who thinks enough of you to even bother giving you a gift. Besides, unnecessarily hurting someone's feelings is never a good thing.