The Oatmeal Cookie is a fun and popular shooter with an interesting flavor. This shot tastes good (maybe a little too good) and is supposed to taste like a homemade oatmeal cookie. As often happens with shots, there are a number of ways to make this recipe.
Overall, the Oatmeal Cookie is relatively tame, with butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream making up the majority of the drink. It is when you add the cinnamon schnapps and, particularly, Jagermeister that things get very interesting and the flavor pops and it really begins to taste like the cookie.
Jagermeister is not in every Oatmeal Cookie shot, so it's okay if you don't have it in stock. Simply make the drink without it.
If you are looking for a delicious shot that has a distinct flavor without going over the top, the Oatmeal Cookie is a perfect choice. It is a fun addition to any party.
A Few Useful Tips
- Some Oatmeal Cookie recipes call for an equal pour of the butterscotch, Irish cream, and cinnamon liqueurs. For the average shot glass, you will want to measure out between 1/3 and 1/2 ounce of each.
- The Oatmeal Cookie can also be served on the rocks in an old-fashioned glass. Garnish it with raisins on a cocktail pick.
- Buttershots, Baileys, and Goldschlager are the most commonly used brands for the three liqueurs.
An Oatmeal Cookie Shot with a Hint of Orange
Personally, I prefer the first Oatmeal Cookie recipe, but this one is enjoyable as well. This recipe skips the cinnamon schnapps and instead uses an orange liqueur. Most often that is Grand Marnier.
To make this drink, shake and strain equal parts orange liqueur, butterscotch schnapps, and Irish cream into a shot glass.
The Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Shot
Jagermeister is back in the Oatmeal Raisin Cookie and we also find rum and a coffee liqueur in this recipe. Quite often, a 151-proof rum is used here, but any rum will do just fine.
To make this drink, shake equal parts Jagermeister, cinnamon schnapps, rum, coffee liqueur, and Irish cream with ice and strain into an old-fashioned glass.
Pouring this shot is a little tricky because you want to fit an equal pour of five distilled spirits into a shot glass that is around 2 ounces.When we factor in dilution from shaking it with ice, that means that you would have to pour about 1/4 ounce of each ingredient. That's tough!
Two options can fix this problem:
- Make two or three shots at one time! If you were to pour 1-ounce of each ingredient, this would create about 5 1/2 ounces after shaking. Divide that into two tall shot glasses and share with a friend.
- Strain the shot into a small tumbler as suggested in the recipe. You can still make more than one drink at the same time and won't have to worry about wasting a single drop!
How Strong are These Oatmeal Cookie Shot?
Let's assume that we mix these shots with the popular brands mentioned above and use Kahlua and an 80-proof rum in the Oatmeal Raisin Cookie. With those assumptions, we can estimate the alcohol content of each shot and it would look like this:
- Oatmeal Cookie: 16% ABV (32 proof)
- Oatmeal Cookie with Grand Marnier: 13% ABV (26 proof)
- Oatmeal Raisin Cookie: 28% ABV (56 proof)
As you can see, the rum and Jagermeister make a significant difference in the Oatmeal Raisin Cookie. If you're looking for the strongest shot of the night (other than straight tequila), that's a good choice.