Cooking Stuffing: Safety Tips, Quantity Chart and More

Stuffing
Ngoc Minh & Julian Wass/ Getty Images

Stuffing, or dressing - depending on whether it's cooked inside your turkey or not - is a marvelous way to take stale chunks of bread and transform them into a savory, aromatic side dish to serve with your Thanksgiving dinner. In other words, another vehicle for gravy.

Stuffing and Dressing Cooking Tips

Whether you give it a quick makeover with some chopped onions, celery, and a few simple seasonings, or the deluxe treatment with added diced apples, raisins, or even oysters; stuffing is, at its core, chunks of bread.

Not just any bread, mind you. To make stuffing, your bread needs to be stale. This is because stale bread becomes stiffer as it dries out. Fresh bread, because it's soft, will produce a soggy stuffing, similar in texture to turkey-flavored pudding.

Fortunately, stale bread is easy to obtain. Simply start with fresh bread and let it sit out on the counter overnight. If you want to be really thorough, you can let the bread sit out overnight, then cut it into cubes and let the cubes sit out for a second night.

Or if you're in a hurry you can toast the cubes in a 275 F oven for about 15 minutes. The objective is to dry it out, not necessarily brown it. Although if you want to brown it a little, bump your oven up to about 300 F.

Stuffing Calculation Chart

You can refer to the chart below to determine how much stuffing you'll need, both in terms of servings, as well as the size of the turkey (or chicken) you want to stuff.

The smaller quantities will work for roasting chickens. For turkeys, concentrate on the last three rows of the table.

Quantity of StuffingSize of BirdNumber of Servings
2 cups3 to 4 pounds2 to 3
3 cups5 to 6 pounds4 to 5
4 cups6 to 8 pounds6 to 7
6 cups8 to 10 pounds8 to 9
2 quarts10 to 12 pounds10 to 11
3 quarts12 to 15 pounds12 to 16
4 quarts15 to 20 pounds18 to 20

 

Stuffing and Food Safety

Whenever you prepare your stuffing in the bird, you increase the risk of food poisoning. Note that this doesn't mean it's significantly more dangerous than cooking a turkey without stuffing. Just that the risk is increased.

This is for two reasons:

  • A stuffed turkey cooks more slowly, because of its greater mass. A turkey needs to reach an interior temperature of 165 F at the deepest part of the thigh and breast, including the interior of the cavity itself.
  • The stuffing comes in contact with the raw interior of the turkey, as well as the juices that are produced during cooking, which means that the stuffing itself, measured at the center, must reach 165 F. Note that the turkey itself may be done before the center of the stuffing is cooked through.

Therefore, you'll need to use an instant-read thermometer to measure the temperature in the center of the stuffing.

Here's something you probably wouldn't guess from the fact that it's called stuffing: You actually do not want to stuff the stuffing into the cavity of the bird.

Packing the stuffing into the bird too tightly will create a food safety hazard, since the denser packed stuffing will take longer to cook. But it also creates a quality issue: instead of being light and fluffy, stuffing that's packed too tightly will have the consistency of cement.

Instead, toss the stuffing gently when you mix it, and spoon it loosely into the cavity of the bird. Another reason to use a light touch is that stuffing expands when it cooks as the starches in the bread absorb the poultry juices. If it's packed too tightly, the walls of the turkey's body cavity could rupture.

See below for an idea for what to do with excess stuffing instead of packing it into the bird.

More Stuffing Tips

  • The heels of loaves of bread are great to save for making stuffing. If you bake your own bread, you probably no longer regard those end pieces as disposable. On the other hand, kids aren't always fond of them, so you can set them aside for stuffing. This has the added benefit of letting them go stale.
  • If you, or someone you know, are on a gluten-free diet, you can use gluten-free bread in your stuffing. Your gluten-free guests will thank you, and no one else will notice the difference.
  • Fresh sage is a great herb to use for stuffing since it proliferates in the autumn, and it's a good herb to harvest shortly before the first frost.
  • If you mix up a batch of stuffing and find that you've made more than will fit in the bird, you can cook the rest in a baking dish in the oven. Just slide the dish into the oven with the turkey about an hour before you're planning to take it out. It'll crisp up on the top, giving you two different stuffings, each with a different texture. 

A Brief History of Stuffing

Stuffing has been around for a long time: recipes exist from the 4th or 5th centuries. But the practice was likely common at least as far back as the Bronze Age, when the earliest evidence of the domestication of chickens appears.

Indeed, it would be surprising if frugal cooks from bygone days did not take advantage of the empty body cavity a poultry carcass offers. If there's a fundamental culinary principle common to cultures everywhere, it's "fill anything hollow with something tasty."

As for North America, one of the main regional variations is the type of starch (not necessarily bread) that was used. 

In the south, cornbread stuffing is the norm. In New England, stuffing historically included chestnuts and oysters. San Franciscans, unsurprisingly, look to sourdough bread for their stuffing. In Pennsylvania, leftover mashed potatoes took the place of the bread.

What all these approaches have in common is taking a basic starchy ingredient and transforming it by cooking inside the bird. Thus producing a filling dish that is infused with the flavors and aromas of the roasted poultry.