In an interesting and convenient twist, here are two drinks made with the same four ingredients. Which you choose to go with will depend on if you are looking for a stronger base or one with more of a focus on herb and citrus.
The Surprised Cocktail recipe is the first, and typically this calls for Jamaican rum. These tend to be more flavorful, though if you have a favorite rum that is rich in taste, I encourage you to use that.
When it comes to the other ingredients, I highly recommend fresh squeezed orange juice. This ingredient is the backbone of the drink that brings everything together and it pairs nicely with the caraway of the kummel.