25 Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

thanksgiving pumpkin pie
Susan Brooks-Dammann / Stocksy United

Looking for unique and delicious pies to serve this Thanksgiving? Maybe you've had some good luck with store bought pies, but now you're ready to go beyond classic apple and pumpkin and try something new this year. Well, look no further–these pie recipes range from creative to classic, from fancy to fresh. We've also included some fantastic homemade crust options for the daring chef.

  • 01 of 25
    The Spruce

    This pie may be a Kentucky Derby tradition, but it also makes for a delicious Thanksgiving dessert. Chocolate and walnuts are a great fall flavor combination.

  • 02 of 25
    William Shaw / Getty Images

    If you're looking for something tart and fruity, then this is the pie for you. We reccomend using Bramley or Granny Smith apples.

  • 03 of 25
    Will Heap / Getty Images

    What would Thanksgiving be without an apple pie? This is an easy and classic recipe that everyone at the table will enjoy.

  • 04 of 25
    Diana Rattray

    This is another great dessert for the chocolate-lovers at your Thanksgiving dinner. The texture is smooth like custard and the flavor is rich like a brownie!

    Continue to 5 of 25 below.
  • 05 of 25
    Diana Rattray

    With just the right amount of spice, this recipe makes the perfect pumpkin pie. Pair it with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream–or both.

  • 06 of 25
    Jason Poole / Getty Images

    Maple, brown sugar and pecan are a match made in heaven. This buttery fall pie will win over all of your guests.

  • 07 of 25
    Steven Gorgos / Getty Images

    For a healthy and guilt-free dessert, try this vegan tofu peanut butter pie. If you love pretzels, chocolate and loads of PB, this is the pie for you.

  • 08 of 25
    John E. Kelly / Getty Images

    Look no further for the ultimate Thanksgiving chocolate pie. This recipe is the perfect dessert, complete with whipped cream topping.

    Continue to 9 of 25 below.
  • 09 of 25
    Maren Caruso / Getty Images

    Forgot to prepare a dessert for Thanksgiving? In a rush? These 10-Minute Banana Pudding Pies are a fantastic fix when you don't have a ton of time to make a fancy pie.

  • 10 of 25
    Diana Rattray

    If you're already stressed on Thanksgiving and looking for a pie that's easy to make, but still delivers on delicious taste, we definitely recommend this apple cranberry pie recipe for a simple taste of the season!

  • 11 of 25
    Jay's Photo / Getty Images

    This delicious and healthy vegan blueberry pie uses Phyllo crust, which saves you a ton of time and energy. If you're feeling ambitious, you can try making your own crust instead.

  • 12 of 25
    Smneedham / Getty Images

    With a dairy and a gluten allergy, you probably thought you'd never be able to have pumpkin pie at your Thanksgiving (or at least a good one). With this great recipe, using gluten-free flour and coconut milk as substitutes, you'll be able to experience this Thanksgiving favorite.

    Continue to 13 of 25 below.
  • 13 of 25
    Schon & Probst / Getty Images

    We recommend tart cherries for this classic cherry pie. While cherries are in season in the summer, fall is the perfect time for delicious tart cherries.

  • 14 of 25
    Diana Rattray

    If you're making a meringue pie this Thanksgiving, this is the ultimate recipe. Use superfine sugar for the best taste and cream of tartar to add stability to your delicate creation.

  • 15 of 25
    Verdina Anna / Getty Images

    Rhubarb pies are a seriously underrated fall dessert. Serve this delicious dish up with buttery oats, vanilla ice cream and an after-dinner cocktail.

  • 16 of 25
    Diana Rattray

    Apple pie is a great standby and a classic dish on Thanksgiving, but try mixing it up a little with a fresh pear pie, topped with beautifully latticed crust.

    Continue to 17 of 25 below.
  • 17 of 25
    Brian Leatart / Getty Images

    We know this isn't a pie recipe, but this cheesecake is so perfect for fall and Thanksgiving, we had to include it. This is easy to make using the same canned pumpkin you would use for pumpkin pie.

  • 18 of 25
    YinYang / Getty Images

    For an extra zing at your Thanksgiving table, try this bourbon-infused pecan pie: a classic southern dish that will be sure to keep the party going!

  • 19 of 25
    Getty Images

    Impress your guests with this easy upgrade from a classic apple pie. Pick your favorite kind of apple, or even mix a few together! Using ready-made pie crust dough makes this recipe even simpler.

  • 20 of 25
    Christopher Bell / Getty Images

    This no-bake yogurt and cool-whip pie is as easy as it is refreshing. Spend less time in front of the oven and more time with your family by serving this delicious dish at your Thanksgiving.

    Continue to 21 of 25 below.
  • 21 of 25
    Samere Fahim Photography / Getty Images

    Fresh strawberries, custard filling and easy store-bought pastry shell come together in this sweet strawberry cream pie. If you're sick of apples by Thanksgiving, a strawberry pie is a great way to switch up your dessert menu.

  • 22 of 25
    JMichl / Getty Images

    Pair this pie crust with a gluten-free pie filling and you're all set for a healthy and inclusive Thanksgiving dinner!

  • 23 of 25
    The Spruce

    Not a fan of graham cracker pie crust? This is a delicious recipe for creating a flaky pie crust without any gluten!

  • 24 of 25
    DNY59 / Getty Images

    This fluffy and light hot water pie crust is unbelievably easy and seriously delicious. This unique recipe is sure to be a hit in your house.

    Continue to 25 of 25 below.
  • 25 of 25
    Leah Maroney

    A flaky crust that will go well with any Thanksgiving pie. We reccomend using butter for the ultimate flaky experience and the best possible flavor.