It's time to buy a new washer. What type do you choose: a standard top-loading machine with a center agitator or one of the high-efficiency front-loading or top-loading washers?
For many years, standard top-loading washers were the only type available to consumers in the United States; while at the same time In the rest of the world, front loaders were leading sellers. Today, the United States is seeing a surge of new high-efficiency (HE) front- and top-loading washers from manufacturers in the marketplace.
Now that there are more choices and standard and high-efficiency washers offer both advantages and disadvantages; which one should you purchase?
Top- and Front-Loading HE Washers vs. Standard Top-Loading Washers
In addition to size, color, and price, there are several factors to consider when selecting a type of washer. Take a look at this head-to-head comparison chart of top- and front-loading high-efficiency washers vs. standard top-loading washers and the explanation of the winner in each factor.
Top-Loading and Front-Loading High-Efficiency Washers
|Standard Top-Loading Washers|
|Gentleness to Clothing||X|
|Energy Savings with Energy Star||X|
|Comfort in Loading/Unloading||X||X|
|Adding Items to Cycle||X (Top-loading HE washer only)||X|
|Washer/Dryer Space Requirements||X (Front-loading HE washer only)|
|Life Expectancy & Repair Costs|
Wear and Tear on Clothing Winner: HE Top- and Front-Loading Washers
High-efficiency top-loading washers use a plate in the bottom of the washer tub to gently move clothes through the water and detergent. Standard top loaders use a central agitator with paddles to move clothing briskly in a circle, causing more wear and tear.
Water Use Winner: HE Top- and Front-Loading Washers
Front-loading washer use around 13 gallons of water per load; top-loading high-efficiency machines use 12 to 17 gallons.
A standard top-loading washer uses 30 to 45 gallons per load. To purchase a washer that uses less water, look for the U.S. Department of Energy's blue Energy Star label that indicates these washers use 30 percent less energy and 50 percent less water than other current models.
Detergent Savings Winner: HE Top- and Front-Loading Washers
Front-loading washers and high-efficiency top-loading washers must use specially formulated low-sudsing detergents, marked as "he". Since these washers use less water, they also need very little detergent, no more than two teaspoons per load. All major detergent manufacturers now offer their best brands in an he formula which can also be used in a standard washer.
Energy Use Winner: HE Top- and Front-Loading Washers
Since front- and top-loading high-efficiency washers use less water, they are the more energy efficient than standard washers because it takes less energy to heat water. Always look for the energy usage label when comparing washer models.
Comfort in Loading/Unloading: It's a Tie
Front load washers require bending to load and unload, just like a dryer, unless support boxes are made or purchased to raise the washer opening to waist level. Front load appliances are easier to use for those in a wheelchair or those who need to be seated due to balance issues.
Top load washers are easy to load but can be difficult to unload for users with short stature and arms.
Adding Laundry During a Cycle Winner: Both Types of Top-Loading Washers
Items can be added throughout the wash cycle in both types of top-loading washers.
Most front-loading washers lock while in use to prevent water overflow, prohibiting the addition of last-minute laundry. One manufacturer, Samsung, has introduced a front load washer with a small door to add laundry after the cycle has started but it also adds significantly to the purchase price.
Space Utilization Winner: Front-Loading Washer
Front-loading washers can be stacked with a dryer to fit into closets or small areas. Top-loading machines must be placed side by side with a dryer unless you purchase a smaller, compact washer/dryer combo.
Purchase Price Winner: Standard Top-Loading Washer
In the United States, front-loading washers are significantly higher in price than a standard top loader. They do provide savings in energy costs but it will take many years to realize the savings for small families or where energy rates are lower in cost. High-efficiency top-loading washers are less expensive to purchase than front-loading models.
Life Expectancy and Repair Costs Winner: Standard Top-Loading Washer
The average life expectancy of a high-efficiency front- or top-loading washer is 11 years. The life expectancy of a standard top-loading washer is 14 years. Because of all of the many optional wash cycles and extra features, front-loading washers typically have higher repair costs.