Have you ever been tempted to cover exposed tree roots with dirt? The temptation is understandable. Here are just a few of the reasons why such roots can drive homeowners crazy:
- They are unsightly.
- If they occur in a lawn area, they are in the way every time that you mow the grass; hitting them by mistake can damage your mower blade.
- Even if they are not in a lawn area, tree roots sticking up above-ground create an unusable space.
- You or other people can trip over them, so they create a health hazard.
- And to add insult to injury, they can push up through walkways, etc., causing damage to your hardscape that costs you money (for repair), time, energy, and consternation.
Maple trees (Acer) are especially apt to cause these issues. So are beech trees (Fagus; see picture), and anything in the willow family, such as the quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides). As a result of such problems, readers send in questions like the following one all of the time:
"I want to have a load of topsoil delivered and put it over an area of my yard that is all tree roots. This is an area under a big tree. It is unsightly and I can't grow anything else there. I would like to start a shade garden (flowers) under the tree. Would placing soil over the tree roots hurt them any?"
It does seem, at first glance, like it would be perfectly safe to have topsoil brought in and spread it on top of the exposed roots. After all, soil can't be a bad thing for roots, right? It is in their nature, is it not, to grow in the dirt? One can readily see why so many homeowners make this landscaping mistake.
Sure, it may seem safe. In fact, however, this practice can be bad for the health of your tree, so beware the cover-up! Here is why:
The Problem With Covering Exposed Tree Roots With Soil: Why It Can Be Harmful to a Tree
If you are thinking of placing dirt on top of exposed roots, at least you are avoiding an even worse mistake: namely, cutting the roots (and yet some beginners mistakenly do just that). Nonetheless, you need to be cautioned against putting soil over tree roots -- at least any great amount of soil. You see, tree roots need to breathe. They need oxygen, and dumping a thick layer of dirt on them can suffocate them. In fact, if you suffer from exposed roots, there is a good chance that lack of oxygen was the reason that the roots came to the surface, in the first place: They were getting insufficient oxygen with which to breathe, perhaps due to their growing in compacted soil.
Here is the good news, though: A small amount of soil can be spread over exposed tree roots, in two stages (if necessary); this incremental approach gives the tree roots time to adjust. But suddenly covering exposed tree roots with enough soil to start a garden could cause serious harm to the tree.
So what is considered a "small amount?" A 2-inch layer of soil is about right. Better yet, mix in some compost before applying the soil, so that the resulting mix will be lighter and fluffier, thereby reducing the likelihood of suffocating the roots. Sow grass seed over the area to try to keep the soil from washing away. If, a year or so later, you find that the soil did not hold (for whatever reason) and the roots are showing above-ground once again, repeat the procedure.
An alternative idea to "dress up" the area under the tree might be to spread a thin (2 inches) layer of mulch over the tree roots, then lay out container gardens (potted plants) with plants of varying heights and textures. If you find attractive pots and hit upon a color scheme that pleases you, then you may end up with a "garden" that is the envy of the neighborhood.
In extreme cases, where exposed roots are sticking up higher than 2 inches above-ground, it is best to just leave them alone and accept that you have a less than ideal situation (unless you are willing to remove the tree).